HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrespondenceùrreø7o*à*rcre-
Colleen W¡rth
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
ê41
Travis Vickroy <tvickT8@icloud.com >
Monday, January 3, 2022 7:56 AM
Colleen Wirth
Fwd: [External] Correction Letter - BLRE-12-21-7266 permit under review
Sent from my iPad
Begin forwarded message
From: Cu rtis McNeley <CMcNeley@timberlyne.com>
Date: January 3,2022 aL8:46:42 AM CST
To: Travis Vickroy <tvick78@icloud.com>
Cc: James Detterick <jim.detterick@mac.com>
Subject: RE: Correction Letter - BLRE-L2-2L-7266 perm¡t under review
Travis & Jím,
Please see the below response from the engineer on the project.
I am having he plans updated as I spoke about with Travis. I have a team member working on this right
now and will have them over to you for review and submission shortly.
Thank you
Bradley,
Thanks for forwarding me this correction. I checked the county's snow requirement and it does state the
minímum roof design snow load (not ground snow load). I am learning that several counties in Colorado
go by roof load instead of ground, so I will keep this in mind for future projects in CO. I updated the
calculations to reflect 50 psf roof snow load, and all of the members still work. No changes are required
to the plans, so you can forward this email to the county for their record or I can reach out to them
dírectly. Please let me know which you prefer.
Thanks,
Rernington Barrer, PE
Project Engnerr
--+--
UzMAN| .' : : ,
I 16 East King Street
ÞIalvern, PA 19355
O:610.320.2100
C:610.655.5893
TIMBER NE
CURTIS MCNELEY
PROJECT MANAGER
Office: 888-489-1680 ext. 1'160
Direct: 402-5'18-2336
Address: l16WlstSt lWayne, NE 68787
www.timbertyne.comsand Cteek Posl & Bæfr end I*as T¡mbêr Frañes
have ja¡ned rogeüler,ãs TimberJyne Êroup.
From: Travís Víckroy <tvick78@icloud.com>
Sent: Wednesday, December 29,20219:57 AM
To: Curtis McNeley <CMcNeley@Tim berlyne.com>
Subject: Fwd: Correction Letter - BLRE-1"2-21-7266 permit under review
*CAUTION* External email, attachments and links may be harmful.
Sent from my iPad
Begin forwarded message:
From: Whit Whitaker <wrw3@hotmail.com>
Date: December 28, 2021.atIA:42:2A AM CST
To: Travis Vickroy <tvick78@ícloud.com>
Subiect: Fwd: Correct¡on Letter - BLRE-12-2L-7266 permit under review
Whit Whitaker
970-274-84t2
wrw3@hotmaíl.com
Begin forwarded message:
From: Col I een Wirth <cwí rth @garfíeld-cou nty.com>
Date: December 28,202Lat9:36:27 AM MST
To
Cc
wrw3@hotmail.com
iim.detleríck @ mac.com
2
Subject: FW: Correction Letter- BLRE-12-2L-7266 permit under
review
RE: BLRE-12-21-7266 - building application under review @
L708 CR 1-21l SGJD LLC
Courtesy Message for the SGJD LLC project team:
Email ís being sent to: WRW Log Works & Building Concepts /
Timberlyne Architect / Uzman Engineering
CC: owner for purpose of requestíng owner letter
CC: Dave Argo, Chief Building Officíal
Hello, I have begun examination of the current building
application and blueprints for l-708 CR 121 ín unincorporated
Garfleld County, Colorado.
Following are some comments, concerns and requested
corrections:
RE: DESCRIPTION OF WORK, BUILDING USE, LABELED FLOOR
PLANS, IDENTIFYING ROOM USES
ln viewing application materials I note some varied descriptions
on the proposed building use and scope
Application form states descríbe work "equipment barn"
C.O.001 includes written strike out from Contractor of Record
eliminating ADU from the "sheet index" -
C.O.001 lists SCOPE OF WORK "proposed residence & shop /
ADU...."
Attached C.2.001, C.2.0A2, C.2.003, C.2.004, C.2.005 retaín ADU
in title block and proposed main floor plan references "shop,/
ADU"
Construction drawings by SGM show no loft floor plan or upper
level building use.
While theie is a concurrent septic permit application SEPT-12-
2I-7267, it is unclear what bathroom groups and DWV piping
and fixtures will become connected to the system as no indoor
bathroom groups or plumbing fixtures are shown on pages
received.
Accompanying Structural Sheets 54, 55, 56 imply on elevation
cross sections and floor framing detaíls a main level floor plan
and loft floor plan - but all floor framed areas are "silent" or
"moot" on the proposed use(s) of the space.
An earlier received subsoil study by K+A for this address
includes a study for foundation design of a proposed house, adu
/ storage and barn at Buck Point Ranch dated May 24,2021.
REQU ESTED CORRECTIONS:
L. Property owner to send a signed letter stating and
reconfirming all of the planned use(s) for the building
2
space. Please email copy to me directly at cwirth@earfield-
co u ntv. co m < m a i lto : cw i rth (@ s a rf i el d -co u ntv. co m >
2. Su[¡rrril. (2)sets r.rf updaLetl architecl"ural fluur plans. Strike
out any old, deleted or erroneous building use
references. Clearly label the story level (main, loft etc). Label
all room uses. Loft plan must include the proposed square feet
for the loft floor space. Label proposed bathrooms if any apply,
including location and type of proposedfuture plumbíng
fixtures. Label location and fuel type of proposed mechanical
equipment (i.e. hot water heater, wall or ceillng mounted
heaters, HVAC, furnaces, or other appliances).
STRUCTURAL CORRECTION
1". Request an email response from the Structural Engineer of
Record concerning snowload measured atthe roof Pf. Please
view GarCo Snow Load Requirements for properties over 7,000
ft elevation. General notes by the Engineer of Record líst a
ground snow load at 50 PSF. Garfield County's policy is
measured at the roof Pf (not ground Pg). The Engineer of
Record can recheck design calculations and provide email
response or confirmation dírectly to cwirth@garfield-
cou ntv. comcmailto:cwirth @garfield-county.com>. ( lf no
further framing plan changes result from Pf calculations, an
email by the Engineer of Record will suffice without
resubmission of the actual structural plan pages).
LOFT FLOOR PLAN & OPEN TO BELOW QUESTTON / n¡QUrSr¡O
CORRECTION:
L. What fall prevention methods will be constructed to protect
the upper level loft floor system from fall hazards to "open to
below" space? Reading sheet 56, l'm a little unclear what is
proposed.... where floor system ends and how much of space ís
open to below? With there be a half- knee wall? Or an open
guard railing detail simílar with the stair framing and guard
details found on S13? lf there is a new loft guard detail or fall
protection descriptíon to add to the plan pages, please email
copy to cwirth @sa rf ield-cou nty. com<ma¡lto :cwirth @sa rfiel d-
countv.com>.
Answers to items #L-2 will help confirm whether (if any)fire-
rated floor, wall, ceilíng assemblies pertain ín the building, OR if
the building use and finished floor area necessitates fire-
sprinklering under the current adopted fire code. Answers to
item #L will help confirm which building height zoníng height
limitation pertains for the building use. Whatever help you can
offer on the above 4 items is most appreciated.
Best,
4
Colleen Wirth
Plans Examiner
Garfield County Building Division
108 8th Street, Suite 401"
Glenwood Springs, CO 81601"
cwirth (ôsarfield-cou ntv Ito:cwirth tôsarfield-
countv.com>
office (970) 945-L377 ext. l-61-0
5
aroroad*æ-
Colleen W¡rth
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
James Detterick <jim.detterick@mac.com >
Tuesday, December 28,2021 8:17 PM
Colleen Wirth
wrw3@hotmail.com
[External] Re: Correction Letter - BLRE-1 2-21-7266 permit under review
ASCE Stand ard 7-16 Snow Loads.docx; GarCo Snow Load Reqts.pdf
Oør* /b/Ør*an
bra4þ /¿se(<:
Good evening Colleen,
Thanks for the note and follow up, much appreciated and ít's nice to meet you over email. Apologies for any
confusion. lndeed over the course of the last year my wife and I have debated different use ideas around this structure f
barn but we landed on only utílizing it as an equipment barn and not an ADU, which is probably why different versions of
the drawings over different time periods created older edits / strike outs. lt will be heated and insulated and will have a
bathroom in it (sink, toilet and shower), but it's use wíll be for ranch equipment and storage. I will build a simple work
bench area and will store a tractor, some UTV's and other vehicles and equipment. lf you need me to I am happy to
send you a signed letter as requested, ís an email / soft copy sufficient? Just let me know what you need from me and I
can turn it around ímmediately.
Thanks again,
Jim
Sent from my iPad
On Dec 28,202I, at 9:36 AM, Colleen Wirth <cwirth@garfield-county-com> wrote:
RE: BLRE-l2-2t-7266 - building application under review @
L7A8 CR 121 / SGJD LLC
Courtesy Message forthe SGJD LLC project team
Email is being sent to: WRW Log Works & Building Concepts / Timberlyne Architect / Uzman
Engineering
CC: owner for purpose of requesting owner letter
CC: Dave Argo, Chief Building Official
Hello, I have begun examination of the current building application and blueprints for 1-708 CR
L2t in uninco rpo rated Ga rfie ld County, Colorado'
Following are some comments, concerns and requested corrections
RE: DESCRIPTION OF WORK, BUILDING USE, LABELED FLOOR PLANS,IDENTIFYING ROOM
USES
ln viewing application mäterials I note some varied descriptions on the proposed building use
änd scope
Applicotion form stotes describe work "equipment barn"
C.O.001 includes written strike out from Contractor of Record eliminoting ADU from the "sheet
index" -
C.O.001 lists SCOPE OF WORK "proposed residence & shop / ADU...."
Attached C.2.007, C.2.002, C.2.003, C.2.004, C.2.005 retain ADIJ in title block ond proposed main
floor plan references "shop/ ADU"
Construction drowings.by SGM show no loftfloor plan or upper level building use.
While there is o concurrent septic permit applicotion SEPT-12-21-7267, it is unclear what
bathroom groups and DWV piping and fixtures will become connected to the system es no
indoor bathroom groups or plumbing fixtures are shown on pages received.
Accompanying Structural Sheets 54, 55, 56 imply on elevation cross sectíons and floor framing
details a main level floor plon and loft floor plan - but all floor framed oreas are "sílent" ar
"moot" on the proposed use(s) of the space.
An earlier received subsoil study by K+A for this address includes a study for foundation design
of o proposed house, adu / storage and barn at Buck Point Ranch dated May 24, 2021.
REQUESTED CORRECTIONS:
1. Property owner to send a signed letter stating and reconfirming all of the planned use(s)
forthe building space. Please email copy to me directly at cwi rth @ea rfield-cou ntv.com
2. Submit (2) sets of updated architectural floor plans. Strike out any old, deleted or
erroneous buílding use references. Clearly label the story level (main, loft etc). Label all
room uses. Loft plan must include the proposed square feet for the loft floor
space. Label proposed bathrooms if any apply, íncluding location and type of
proposed/future plumbing fixtures. Label location and fuel type of proposed
mechanical equipment (i.e. hot water heater, wall or ceiling mounted heaters, HVAC,
furnaces, or other appliances).
STRUgTURAL CORRECTION :
3. Request an email response from the Structural Engineer of Record concerning snowload
measured at the roof Pf. Please view GarCo Snow Load Requirements for properties
over 7,000 ft elevation. General notes by the Engineer of Record list a ground snow
load at 50 PSF. Garfield County's policy is measured at the roof Pf (not ground
Pg). The Engineer of Record can recheck design calculations and provide email
response or confirmatíon directly to cwirth@garfield-countv.com. ( lf no further
framing plan changes result from Pf calculations, an email by the Engineer of Record will
suffice without resubmíssion of the actual structural plan pages).
LOFT FLOOR PLAN & OPEN TO BELOW QUESTTON / NEQUCSTED CORRECTION:
4. What fall prevention methods will be constructed to protect the upper level loft floor
system from fall hazards to "open to below" space? Reading sheet 56, l'm a little
unclear what is proposed.... where floor system ends and how much of space is open to
below? With there be a half- knee wall? Or an open guard railíng detail similar with
the stair framing and guard details found on S13? lf there is a new loft guard detail or
fall protection description to add to the plan pages, please email copy to
cwi rth @ ga rfield-cou ntv.com.
2
Answers to items #1-2 will help confirm whether (if any) fire-rated floor, wall, ceiling assemblies
pertain in the building, OR if the building use and finished floor area necessitates fire-
sprinklering under the current adopted fire code. Answers to item #L will help confirm which
building height zoníng height limitation pertains forthe building use. Whatever help you can
offer on the above 4 items is most appreciated.
Best,
Colleen Wirth
Plans Examiner
Garfield County Building Division
LO8 8th Street, Suite 401-
Glenwood Springs, CO 8l-601
cwírth @sarfield-cou ntv. com
office (970) 945-t377 ext. 1610
3