Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
1.00 General Application Materials_Part2
00 10'20' 62/$5396<67(0 62 QTY QCELL 400W MODULES 24.8 KW SYSTEM SIZE 20 DEG TILT, 180 AZIMUTH EST. 37,418 KWH PER YEAR 45'-5 916" 11'-8 716" 22'-01116" 51'-1112" 55'-518" 87,/,7<0(7(5 6(59,&(',6&211(&7 39$&',6&211(&7 (665$3,'6+87'2:1 SOLAR PV SIGNAGE LABEL: PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM AC DISCONNECT DUAL POWER SUPPLY PHOTOVOLTAIC AC DISCONNECT OPERATING CURRENT 125 AMPS OPERATING VOLTAGE 240 VOLTS WARNING-ELECTRIC SHOCK HAZARD DO NOT TOUCH TERMINALS TERMINALS ON BOTH LINE AND LOAD SIDE MAY BE ENERGIZED IN THE OPEN POSITION WARNING-ELECTRIC SHOCK HAZARD IF A GROUND FAULT IS INDICATED THEN THE NORMALLY GROUNDED CONDUCTORS MAY BE ENERGIZED IN THE OPEN POSITION CAUTION: PANEL MAY BE ENERGIZED BY UTILITY OR CUSTOMER SOLAR PV SYSTEM CAUTION: BOTH TOP AND LOWER SOCKET JAWS MAY BE ENERGIZED BY SOURCE AND CUSTOMER SOLAR PV SYSTEM WARNING; PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER SOURCE PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM EQUIPPED WITH RAPID SHUTDOWN RAPID SHUTDOWN DISCONNECTS RAPID SHUT DOWN SWITCH FOR SOLAR PV SYSTEM LOCATION: PV DISCONNECT PV DISCONNECT PV DISCONNECT MDP MDP UTILITY METER INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR CONDUIT, RACEWAYS, ENCLOSURES, AND CABLE ASSEMBLIES MDP PV DISCONNECT PV DISCONNECT © 2 0 2 3 C O N U N D R U M T E C H N O L O G I E S TH E I N F O R M A T I O N A N D D E S I G N I N T E N T C O N T A I N E D O N T H I S DO C U M E N T I S T H E P R O P E R T Y O F C O N U N D R U M TE C H N O L O G I E S , L L C . N O P A R T O F T H I S I N F O R M A T I O N M A Y BE U S E D W I T H O U T T H E P R I O R W R I T T E N P E R M I S S I O N O F CO N U N D R U M T E C H N O L O G I E S , L L C . C O N U N D R U M TE C H N O L O G I E S S H A L L R E T A I N A L L C O M M O N L A W ST A T U T O R Y A N D O T H E R R E S E R V E D R I G H T S , I N C L U D I N G CO P Y R I G H T T H E R E T O . DE T T E R I C K R A N C H CR 1 2 1 CA R B O N D A L E , C O DENVER OFFICE: 6899 PECOS ST UNIT C DENVER, CO 80221 VAIL OFFICE: 210 EDWARDS VILLAGE SUITE A-107 EDWARDS, CO 81632 ASPEN OFFICE: 135 W MAIN ST SUITE F ASPEN, CO 81611 PHONE: 970.688.5261 FAX: 928.396.2329 DESIGN@CONUNDRUMTECHNOLOGIES.COM REVISIONS SITE PLAN AE1.0 SOLAR SITE PLAN1.0 DATEISSUE DESCRIPTION 6.8.2301 BY INITIAL KW 6,7(3/$1 ,03$&7$1$/<6,6 G. Impact Analysis Where the proposed development will impact specific features of the site, the Applicant shall describe both the existing conditions and the potential changes created by the project. The Impact Analysis shall include a complete description of how the Applicant will ensure that impacts will be mitigated and standards will be satisfied. The following information shall be included in the Impact Analysis. 1. Adjacent Land Use. Existing use of adjacent property and neighboring properties within 1,500-foot radius. Existing use of adjacent property and neighboring properties within a 1,500-ft. radius is primarily Rural residential and Bureau of land management. See map and GIS representations below. 2. Site Features. A description of site features such as streams, areas subject to flooding, lakes, high ground water areas, topography, vegetative cover, climatology, and other features that may aid in the evaluation of the proposed development. The closest water body is West Coulter Creek which lies 500 ft east of the project site. Flooding is not a major concern. Climatology is semi-arid, and the primary vegetation of the area includes grasses, scrub oak, juniper, and sage. According to FEMA flood panel 0802051500B there is no high risk of flooding in this area. It is outside of any flood zone. FEMA flood zone map attached below. The landscape position for the solar field is considered summit and will not be impacted by stormwater drainage. The slope shape is convex – convex (VV) towards the southwest. Existing topography in the vicinity of the solar array slopes from northeast towards the southwest at grades of between 1.0 to 31.0 percent. Grades are not proposed to change under proposed conditions. 3. Soil Characteristics. A description of soil characteristics of the site that have a significant influence on the proposed use of land. According to the Web Soil Survey for the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS), soils associated with this subject property are classified as map units 59-Iyers loam and 67 Jerry-Millerlake loams. Iyers has grades of between 6 to 25 percent, which does agree with field observation. Jerry-Millerlake has grades between 25 to 45 percent, which also agrees with field observations. Soil composition can be seen in the Web Soil Survey information below 4. Geology and Hazard. A description of geologic characteristics of the area including any potential natural or manmade hazards and a determination of what effect such factors would have on the proposed use of the land. Approximately 300 million years ago, a pair of mountain ranges collectively named the Ancestral Rockies formed on either side of the Roaring Fork Valley. Once the ancestral sea dried up, it left a thick layer called the Eagle Valley Evaporite. The pale gypsum visible throughout the area is most apparent near the town that takes its name. In addition to this, sandstone, conglomerates, and shales were deposited by streams and rivers coming off of these ancient peaks. On this side of the Rockies this is known as the Maroon Formation. There are no geologic characteristics in the proposed area, including any potential natural or manmade hazards, that would significantly affect or impact the proposed solar PV array. 5. Groundwater and Aquifer Recharge Areas. Evaluation of the relationship of the subject parcel to Floodplains, the nature of soils and subsoils and their ability to adequately support waste disposal, the Slope of the land, the effect of sewage effluents, and the pollution of surface Runoff, stream flow, and groundwater. The elevation of the proposed solar PV system is approximately 6,884 ft. above sea level, almost 500 ft. above the Roaring Fork River Valley below; additionally, the project site slopes downhill toward the aforementioned Roaring Fork River Valley. The proposed site is not located in a flood plain. The nature of the soils and subsoils and their ability to adequately support waste disposal is not applicable to the project; all project-related wastes will be disposed of within 10 days of project completion, and there will be no wastewater or sewage effluents generated by or associated with the project. Likewise, there will be no appreciable pollution generated during system installation or during subsequent operation that would have the potential to pollute surface runoff, stream flow, or groundwater. 6. Environmental Impacts. Determination of the existing environmental conditions on the parcel to be developed and the effects of development on those conditions, including: a. Determination of the long-term and short-term effect on flora and fauna; The project will have no detrimental effects on flora or fauna during either installation or subsequent operation. Natural grass seed will be applied to cover any disturbed dirt from the installation process. b. Determination of the effect on designated environmental resources, including critical wildlife habitat; The project will have no detrimental effects on any designated environmental resources, including critical wildlife habitat. While there are elk, deer and other large mammals present on the property, the proposed solar field takes up a very small portion of the property allowing for normal wildlife migrations. The majority of the property remains natural and untouched. c. Impacts on wildlife and domestic animals through creation of hazardous attractions, alteration of existing native vegetation, blockade of migration routes, use patterns, or other disruptions; The proposed project should attract neither wildlife nor domestic creatures; in the event that any beasts should be attracted, ¼ in. hardware cloth/protective grating shall cover the rear of the ground-mounted array, not allowing access to wires or electrical components. From the arrays to the point of interconnection (POI), conductors shall be underground and conduit-protected, and at the equipment mast near the utility mast (POI), conduit and/or electro-metallic tubing (EMT) shall cover any conductors, not allowing access. To the best of our knowledge, the ground-mounted solar PV arrays should not affect, block, or disrupt any migration routes or use patterns, nor cause any other appreciable disruptions. While there are elk, deer and other large mammals present on the property the proposed solar field takes up a very small portion of the property allowing for normal wildlife migrations. The majority of the property remains natural and untouched. d. Evaluation of any potential radiation hazard that may have been identified by the State or County Health Departments. To the best of our knowledge, there is no known potential radiation hazard at the project location that has been identified by any health departments. The solar PV arrays themselves have no radioactive characteristics. 7. Nuisance. Impacts on adjacent land from generation of vapor, dust, smoke, noise, glare or vibration, or other emanations. The solar PV arrays shall generate no appreciable amounts of vapor, dust, smoke, noise, glare or vibration, or any other notable emanations that would impact adjacent land. The nearest adjacent land to the project site will be thousands of feet away. 8. Hours of Operation. The Applicant shall submit information on the hours operation of the proposed use. The solar PV shall generate power during times between sunrise and sunset. There is no associated noise or moving parts. $UWLFOH6WDQGDUGV&RPSOLDQFH Article 7: Standards Division 1. General Approval Standards 7-101. Zone District Use Regulations The Land Use Change shall comply with Article 3, Zoning, including any applicable zone district use restrictions and regulations. The site in question- 1708 County Road 121, Carbondale (unincorporated Garfield County), CO 81623- is classified as Rural (R) zoning, as defined in Garfield County Article 3: Zoning, Division 1. General Provisions, 3- 101: Establishment of Zone Districts. The definition of Rural zoning classification includes the following: Uses, densities, and standards established for this zone district are intended to protect the existing character of the area from uncontrolled and unmitigated residential, commercial, and industrial use. The zone district provides for the use of natural resources, recreational development, rural residential, and other uses. The addition of the proposed ground-mount solar photovoltaic (PV) system shall be controlled, and by no means unmitigated. The use of the “natural resource” of the sun, as well as a rural residential classification are both consistent with the permitted Rural zoning classification uses as defined above. Existing land uses, as well as the proposed solar PV array, both comply with the lot size, set-back, and height standards as given in Table 3-201: Zone District Dimensions. The project will not conflict with any County frontage requirements as defined in 3-202. General Restrictions and Measurements. The project does not conflict with any provisions as set forth in the following sections: •3-301: Floodplain Overlay Regulations •3-302: Drinking Water Constraints Overlay Regulations •3-303: Airport/Heliport Influence Area Overlay Regulations As classified under Table 3-403: Use Table, the lot’s principal Use Category is Household Living, and the primary Use Type is Dwelling, Single-Unit (Residential Use). The proposed solar PV system addition falls under Use Type Solar Energy System, Small (Rural (R) Residential District). Under Garfield County’s classification system, this is listed as “A,” or as requiring an Administrative Review. 7-102. Comprehensive Plan and Intergovernmental Agreements The Land Use Change is in general conformance with the Garfield County Comprehensive Plan and complies with any applicable intergovernmental agreement. The Land Use Change is in general conformance with the Garfield County Comprehensive Plan and complies with any applicable intergovernmental agreement. 7-103. Compatibility The nature, scale, and intensity of the proposed use are compatible with adjacent land uses. The nature and scale of the proposed use are installation of a 62 module, 24.8 kW ground-mounted solar PV array in the southwestern portion of the property, approximately 300 ft. north from the existing home, where grid interconnection will be achieved. There will be 2 rows, each 31 modules (approximately 49 ft.) wide. The combined footprints of the arrays will be approximately 2085 sq ft., or 0.004997% of the parcel’s 960 acre size. At the proposed tilt angle of 30 degrees. Solar arrays are quite common on rural residential properties. A modestly sized residential array, the proposed array would eliminate the equivalent of approximately 28,460 lb. of carbon dioxide annually. Having been around for several decades commercially, solar PV is an attractive, environmentally beneficial, and commonly accepted part of the modern landscape, both on the residential, as well as commercial, levels. The shortest distance the project parcel is from the nearest public roadway, County Road 121, is approximately 1,700ft. Trees and vegetation to the north, south, and east would obscure the views of the proposed array from the existing neighboring residences. Notice of the proposed array installation shall be sent to the owners of neighboring parcels as well, making them aware of it as well as allowing for comments. There are no planned landscape modifications, and drainage patterns will not be modified. 7-104. Source of Water All applications for Land Use Change Permits shall have an adequate, reliable, physical, long-term and legal water supply to serve the use, except for land uses that do not require water, or that contain Temporary Facilities served by a licensed water hauler. N/A. Project has no water demands for either construction or subsequent usage. 7-105. Central Water Distribution and Wastewater Systems A. Water Distribution Systems. The land use shall be served by a water distribution system that is adequate to serve the proposed use and density. N/A. The proposed solar PV system has no water requirements. B.Wastewater Systems. The land use shall be served by a wastewater system that is adequate to serve the proposed use and density. N/A. The proposed solar PV system has no wastewater requirements. 7-106. Public Utilities A. Adequate Public Utilities Adequate Public Utilities shall be available to serve the land use. The proposed solar PV system will be grid-interactive, connecting with the Holy Cross electric grid at the existing main electric service. Approval has been granted by Holy Cross Energy. B. Approval of Utility Easement by Utility Company. Utility easements shall be subject to approval by the applicable utility companies and where required, additional easements shall be provided for main switching stations and substations. The Applicant shall work with the utility companies to provide reasonably-sized easements in appropriate locations. N/A. There will be no necessary or applicable utility easements; Array shall be set back from Holy Cross Energy distribution lines by required 15 ft. C. Utility Location Unless otherwise provided in this Code, the following conditions shall apply to the location of utility services. N/A. All on-site utility services are existing; no new utility services will be introduced. D. Dedication of Easements. All utility easements shall be dedicated to the public. Drainage easement may be dedicated to either the public or to an HOA. N/A. The proposed project shall have no impact on existing easements, nor introduce any new easements. E. Construction and Installation of Utilities. Applicants shall make the necessary arrangements with each service utility for the construction and installation of required utilities. Utilities shall be installed in a manner that avoids unnecessary removal of trees or excessive excavations, and shall be reasonably free from physical obstructions. All required utilities are existing; no new utility service shall be required. Trenching shall be performed and underground conduit-protected conductors laid, to establish interconnection with the existing Holy Cross Energy utility service. F. Conflicting Encumbrances. Easements shall be free from conflicting legal encumbrances. 7-107. ACCESS AND ROADWAYS. All roads shall be designed to provide for adequate and safe access and shall be reviewed by the County Engineer. A. Access to Public Right-of-Way. All lots and parcels have legal and physical access to a public right-of-way. B.Safe Access. Access to and from the use shall be using existing and established access roadways approved prior to the proposed project. C. Adequate Capacity. Access serving the proposed use shall have the capacity to efficiently and safely service the additional traffic generated by the use. The use shall not cause traffic congestion or unsafe traffic conditions. There shall not be notable impacts to County, State, or Federal roadway System. D. Road Dedications. N/A. All rights-of-way are pre-existing, and shall not be impacted by the proposed project. E. Impacts Mitigated. N/A. Impacts to County roads associated with hauling, truck traffic, and equipment use shall be negligible; traffic associated with the proposed project shall consist of the installation crew arriving in one vehicle in the morning and typically staying on-site until conclusion of work activities at end of work day. F. Design Standards. N/A. Roadways, surfaces, curbs and gutters, and sidewalks are in-place and pre-existing. They shall not be altered or affected by the proposed project. 7-108. USE OF LAND SUBJECT TO NATURAL HAZARDS. No land subject to any identified Natural and Geologic Hazards shall be developed for the proposed project. 7-109. FIRE PROTECTION. A. Adequate Fire Protection. Adequate fire protection will be provided for each land use change as required by the local fire protection district. B. Subdivisions. Adequate primary and secondary access, fire lanes, fire protection water sources, fire hydrants, and maintenance provisions for divisions and subdivisions of land in which the proposed project is to be installed are pre-existing, and shall be adequate during the project’s construction and the solar PV array’s subsequent usage. DIVISION 2. GENERAL RESOURCE PROTECTION STANDARDS. 7-201. AGRICULTURAL LANDS. A. No Adverse Effect to Agricultural Operations. N/A. The proposed project shall have no impact, adversely affect, or otherwise limit the viability of any agricultural operations. B.Domestic Animal Controls. N/A. There shall be no dogs or any other domestic animals associated with the proposed project. C. Fences. N/A. Any fences constructed to separate the parcel from adjoining Agricultural Lands or stock drives as required to protect Agricultural Lands are pre-existing. D. Roads. N/A. Access roads to the proposed project site are pre-existing. No new roads shall be constructed during the course of the project. There shall be no notable dust generated during the course of project construction; there shall be no adverse impacts to livestock or crops due to dust during the course of the project. E. Ditches. N/A. The proposed project shall not create, alter, impact, or interfere with any irrigation ditches or ditch rights- of-way. The solar PV array, and any associated equipment, shall not interrupt or otherwise affect the maintenance of any irrigation ditches. The proposed project shall have no associated ditch crossings. There shall be no drainage modifications to any existing drainage patterns. No actions associated with the proposed project shall channel any surface waters into any irrigation ditch. 7-202. WILDLIFE HABITAT AREAS. N/A. The project shall not impact any wildlife habitat areas, either during construction or during subsequent operations. 7-203. PROTECTION OF WATER BODIES. N/A. There are no water bodies on the parcel of the proposed project. 7-204 DRAINAGE AND EROSION. A. Erosion and Sedimentation. Excluding Grading activities for agricultural purposes, development disturbing 1 acre or more is subject to the CDPHE National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit, unless otherwise exempted by CDPHE. N/A. The proposed project shall not disturb 1 acre or more. B.Drainage N/A. The proposed project shall not alter or impact any existing drainage patterns. C.Stormwater Run-Off. These standards shall apply to any new development within 100 feet of a Waterbody and to any other development with 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surface area. N/A. The proposed project shall not be within 100 ft. of a water body, and will not have 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surface area. 7-205. ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY. A. Air Quality. The proposed project shall not cause air quality to be reduced below acceptable levels established by the Colorado Air Pollution Control Division. B. Water Quality. At a minimum, all hazardous materials shall be stored and used in compliance with applicable State and Federal hazardous materials regulations. N/A. There shall be no hazardous materials involved during the construction of, or during the subsequent operation of the proposed project. 7-206. WILDFIRE HAZARDS. A. Location Restrictions. Development associated with the proposed project shall not be located in a severe wildfire Hazard Area with Slopes greater than 30% or within a fire chimney. B. Development Does Not Increase Potential Hazard. The proposed project shall be developed in a manner that does not increase the potential intensity or duration of a wildfire, or adversely affect wildfire behavior or fuel composition. C.Roof Materials and Design. Roof materials shall be made of noncombustible materials or other materials as recommended by the local fire agency. N/A. The proposed solar PV system is ground-mounted. 7-207. NATURAL AND GEOLOGIC HAZARDS. A.Utilities. Above-ground utility facilities located in Hazard Areas shall be protected by barriers or diversion techniques approved by a qualified professional engineer. The determination to locate utility facilities above ground shall be based upon the recommendation and requirements of the utility service provider and approved by the County. N/A. All utilities located on proposed project site are pre-existing; No new utility facilities are to be included in the proposed project. B.Development in Avalanche Hazard Areas. N/A. The proposed project does not lie in an avalanche hazard area. C. Development in Landslide Hazard Areas. N/A. The proposed project does not lie in a landslide hazard area. D. Development in Rockfall Hazard Areas. N/A. The proposed project does not lie in a rockfall hazard area. E. Development in Alluvial Fan Hazard Area. N/A. The proposed project does not lie in an alluvial fan hazard area. F.Slope Development. Development on Slopes 20% or greater shall only be permitted to occur if the Applicant demonstrates that the development complies with the following minimum requirements and standards, as certified by a qualified professional engineer, or qualified professional geologist, and as approved by the County. N/A. The slopes on which the proposed project would be placed are less than 20%. G.Development on Corrosive or Expansive Soils and Rock. N/A. The proposed solar PV array location does not consist of expansive soils and rock. H.Development in Mudflow Areas. N/A. The proposed solar PV array location would not be in a mudflow area. I.Development Over Faults. N/A. The proposed solar PV array location would not be located over a fault. 7-208. RECLAMATION. A. Applicability. These standards shall apply to any development that requires a Land Use Change Permit, including divisions of land, as well as to the following activities: 1. Installation of ISDS. Installation of a new or replacement ISDS. N/A. No ISDSs (or OWTSs (On-site Wastewater Treatment Systems)) are part of the proposed project. 2. Driveway Construction. Any driveway construction that requires a Garfield County Access Permit or a CDOT Access Permit. N/A. There are no driveways in the scope of work of the proposed project. 3. Preparation Area. All areas disturbed during development that do not comprise the longer-term functional areas of the site but are those areas used for the short-term preparation of the site. N/A. There will be no notable site degradation due to short-term site preparation. The installation crew shall park their vehicle on previously disturbed areas, and will not contribute any additional impact. B. Reclamation of Disturbed Areas. Any areas disturbed during development shall be restored as natural-appearing landforms that blend in with adjacent undisturbed topography. Upon complete project installation, any disturbed surfaces shall be stabilized by vegetation or other means to reduce any soil erosion from wind or water, provide forage and cover, prevent fugitive dust as required by State statute, and reduce visual impacts. 1. Contouring and Revegetation. Abrupt angular transitions and linear placement on visible Slopes shall be avoided. Areas disturbed by Grading shall be contoured so they can be revegetated, and shall be planted and have any disturbed and have vegetation established. A uniform vegetative cover shall be established with an individual plant density of at least 70% of pre-disturbance levels within 4 growing seasons. Revegetation cover shall consist of a diversity of native and/or beneficial non-native vegetation species capable of supporting the post-disturbance land use. State- or County-listed noxious weeds, as well as alien invasive species, do not count as part of the 70% cover. To the maximum extent feasible, disturbed areas shall be revegetated to a desired plant community, with composition of weed-free species and plant cover typical to that site. 2. Weed Management. A management plan with appropriate strategies shall be employed for all Garfield County-listed noxious weeds, State of Colorado-listed noxious weeds that are targeted for statewide eradication, and any other invasive species. 3. Application of Topsoil. Topsoil shall be stockpiled and placed on disturbed areas and managed for later use in reclamation. Provisions for salvaging on-site topsoil, a timetable for eliminating topsoil and/or aggregate piles and a plan that provides for soil cover if any disturbances or stockpiles will sit exposed for a period of 90 days or more shall be reviewed and accepted by the Garfield County Vegetation manager. Due to the small-scale nature of this project, all short-term disturbances shall be remediated within 10 days of project completion. Top soil shall be replaced where displaced from ground cover and restored to equal to or better than previously-existing condition. Debris will be cleared from the project site within ten (10) days of project completion. No disturbances or stockpiles shall remain or sit exposed for a period of 90 days or longer. 4.Retaining Walls. Retaining walls made of wood, stone, vegetation, or other materials that blend with the natural landscape shall be used to reduce the steepness of cut slopes and to provide planting pockets conducive to revegetation. There shall only be extremely localized soil disturbance beneath ground-mount racking structure ‘feet.’ The adjustable platform legs allow for variable leg length platform configuration, eliminating the need for slope cutting, particularly for the shallow slope at the proposed project site. 5. Slash Around Homes. To avoid insects, diseases, and wildfire hazards, all vegetative residue, branches, limbs, stumps, roots, or other such flammable lot-clearing debris shall be removed from all areas of the lot in which such materials are generated or deposited, prior to final building inspection approval. Any existing debris will be removed prior to final building inspection approval. 6.Removal of Debris. Within 6 months of substantial completion of soil disturbance, all brush, stumps, and other debris shall be removed from the site. 7.TimeLine Plan. Every area disturbed shall have a timeline approved for the reclamation of the site. N/A. The proposed project is not multi-phase. All of the minor areas cleared shall be restored prior to project completion, and any areas of disturbed vegetation restored. All disturbed areas will be restored within 10 days of completion of the project. DIVISION 3. SITE PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS. Unless a use is explicitly identified elsewhere in this Code as being exempt from 1 or more standards, the following standards shall apply to all uses, divisions of land and PUDs. Single family dwelling units are specifically exempt from these Division 3 standards. 7-301. COMPATIBLE DESIGN. A. Site Organization. The site shall be organized in a way that considers the relationship to streets and lots, solar access, parking, pedestrian access, and access to common areas. N/A. The proposed project has no public access, will not have access to streets, require parking, or involve common areas. Owner and/or maintenance access, should it be required or desired, will be via pedestrian access, through owner’s property. The project will indeed be organized in a way that considers solar access. B. Operational Characteristics. The operations of activities on the site shall be managed to avoid nuisances to adjacent uses relating to hours of operations, parking, service delivery, and location of service areas and docks. N/A. System operation has no associated parking demands, service delivery, or location of service areas or docks. 1. Dust, odors, gas, fumes, and glare shall not be emitted at levels that are reasonably objectionable to adjacent property. 2. Noise shall not exceed State noise standards pursuant to C.R.S., Article 12 of Title 25. 3. Hours of operation shall be established to minimize impacts to adjacent land uses. N/A. Operation of the system shall have no adverse impacts on adjacent land uses. C. Buffering. Buffering shall be installed to mitigate visual, noise, or similar impacts to adjacent property whenever adjacent uses are in a different zone district. N/A. Adjacent uses are not in a different zone district. D.Materials. Exterior facades are constructed with materials that do not detract from adjacent buildings or uses. In addition, the arrays are not visible to adjacent buildings or uses due to presence of trees and forests. 7-302. OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING STANDARDS. A. Off-Street Parking Required. N/A. No additional parking will be required for the arrays once they are operational, as, barring an unexpected malfunction, no additional service shall be required for them once they are operating. B.Off-Street Loading Required. Buildings or structures that are designed or that are substantially altered so as to receive and distribute materials and merchandise by truck shall provide and maintain off-street loading spaces in sufficient number to meet their need. Where the property or use is served or designed to be served by tractor-trailer delivery vehicles, the standards in Table 7-302.B. shall be used in establishing the minimum number of off-street loading berths required. N/A. Barring service needs arising from an unexpected system malfunction, once the solar PV system is operational, there shall be no needs for any type of associated material or merchandise deliveries. C. Continuing Obligation. The provision and maintenance of off-street parking and loading spaces that comply with this Code shall be a continuing obligation of the property owner. N/A. Once the solar PV system has been installed and is operational, there shall be no associated off-street parking or loading space requirements. D. Location of Required Parking Spaces. Required off-street parking spaces shall be located on the same lot or the adjacent lot proximate to the business they are intended to serve. N/A. Once the solar PV system is operational, there shall be no associated off-street parking requirements; in addition, the property is residential, and not a business. E. Loading and Unloading. N/A. The completed and operational solar PV system shall involve no loading or unloading of vehicles serving commercial or industrial uses. F.Parking and Loading Area Surface. N/A. The completed and operational solar PV system shall not have, nor require, any associated parking or loading areas. G.Minimum Dimensions of Parking Areas. N/A. There shall be no parking areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. H. Compact Car Spaces. N/A. There shall be no parking areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. I. Minimum Dimensions of Loading Berths. N/A. There shall be no loading berths necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. J. Handicapped or Accessible Parking. N/A. There shall be no parking areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. K. Unobstructed Access. Each required parking space shall have unobstructed access from a road or Alley, or from an aisle or drive connecting with a road or Alley, except for approved residential tandem parking. N/A. There shall be no parking areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. L. Tandem Parking. N/A. There shall be no parking areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. M. Backing Onto Public Streets Prohibited. N/A. There shall be no parking areas, and thus no associated access driveways therefore, necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. N. Access Driveways. N/A. There shall be no access driveways necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. O. Parking and Loading Area Landscaping and Illumination. N/A. There shall be no parking or loading areas necessary, nor created, for the complete and functioning solar PV system. 7-303. LANDSCAPING STANDARDS A. General Standards. 1. All portions of the site where existing vegetative cover is damaged or removed, that are not otherwise covered with new improvements, shall be successfully revegetated with a mix of native, adaptive, and drought-tolerant grasses, ground covers, trees and shrubs. The density of the re-established vegetation must be adequate to prevent soil erosion and invasion of weeds after 1 growing season. Minor areas where the ground-mount structures’ ‘feet’ will penetrate the earth, potentially damaging small amounts of vegetative cover shall be covered by the new improvements of the solar PV arrays themselves, thus exempting these minor areas. These small holes will also be filled by the structures’ ‘feet’ themselves. The only other area where any vegetation could possibly removed during installation is the trenching area where the underground conductors will be laid. This linear area shall be successfully revegetated with a mix of native, adaptive, and drought-tolerant grasses, ground covers, trees and shrubs, replacing the vegetation damaged or removed. The density of the re-established vegetation shall be adequate to prevent soil erosion and invasion of weeds after 1 growing season. 2.Landscaping shall not obstruct fire hydrants or utility boxes and shall be installed so it will not grow into any overhead utility lines. Trees and shrubs shall not be planted within 4 feet of existing overhead or underground lines. Only Grass seed will be planted in the vicinity of the solar array B. Multi-Family Development. N/A. The proposed project does not lie in a parcel containing multi-family dwellings. C. Subdivision, PUD, and Rural Land Development Exemption. Landscaping in a residential Subdivision, Planned Unit Development, or Rural Land Development Exemption shall be consistent with the character of the development, the unique ecosystem, and specific environment in which the development is located. Any landscaping performed to revegetate any areas of vegetation damaged or removed shall be consistent with the character of the development, the unique ecosystem, and specific environment in which the development is located. D. Plants Compatible with Local Conditions. All plants used for landscaping shall be compatible with the local climate and the soils, drainage, and water conditions of the site. When panting occurs on hillsides, Slopes, drainage ways, or similar natural areas, plant material should duplicate adjacent plant communities both in species composition and special distribution patterns. Whenever possible, drought-resistant varieties of plant materials shall be utilized. Xeriscape design principles and the use of native plant species shall be used when appropriate. All plants used for any landscaping performed to revegetate any areas of vegetation damaged or removed shall be compatible with the local climate and the soils, drainage, and water conditions of the site. When panting occurs on hillsides, Slopes, drainage ways, or similar natural areas, plant material should duplicate adjacent plant communities both in species composition and special distribution patterns. Whenever possible, drought-resistant varieties of plant materials shall be utilized. Xeriscape design principles and the use of native plant species shall be used when appropriate. E. Existing Vegetation. Healthy trees, native vegetation, natural or significant rock outcroppings, and other valuable features shall be preserved and integrated within planting areas. F.Minimum Size. To ensure healthy plant materials are installed in new development, trees and shrubs shall comply with the quality standards of the Colorado Nursery Act, C.R.S. Title 35, Article 26. 3. Deciduous Trees. N/A. No deciduous trees shall be removed, and thus replaced, for landscaping for the proposed project. 4. Coniferous Trees. N/A. No coniferous trees shall be removed, and thus replaced, for landscaping for the proposed project. 5. Ornamental Trees. N/A. No ornamental trees shall be removed, and thus replaced, for landscaping for the proposed project. 6.Shrubs and Vines. Shrubs shall be a minimum of 1 foot in height at time of planting. Vines shall be in a minimum 1 gallon container. Any shrubs planted shall be a minimum of 1 foot in height at time of planting. There shall be no vines removed during the course of the project, and thus replaced. G. Minimum Number of Trees and Shrubs. Trees and shrubs must be grouped in strategic areas and not spread thinly around the site. Where screening is required, plant materials must be sufficient to create a semi-opaque wall of plant material between the property and the adjoining area to be screened. Any trees and shrubs planted shall be grouped in strategic areas and not spread thinly around the site. Where screening is required, plant materials shall be sufficient to create a semi-opaque wall of plant material between the property and the adjoining area to be screened. H. Parking and Storage Prohibited. Areas required as landscaping shall not be used for parking, outdoor storage, and similar uses, but may be used for snow storage if designed in compliance with section 7-305, Snow Storage Standards. Any landscaped areas shall not be used for parking, outdoor storage, and similar uses. I. Clear Vision Area. N/A. The proposed project, and thus any project landscaping, shall not be performed in the Clear Vision Area. J. Landscaping Within Off-Street Parking Areas. N/A. The project does not include any additional parking areas (refer to §7-302. OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING STANDARDS.) 7-304. LIGHTING STANDARDS. N/A. The proposed project does not include any additional exterior lighting. 7-305. SNOW STORAGE STANDARDS. All residential uses except for multi-family are exempt from this section, unless the residential use includes a common outdoor parking area. N/A. As the proposed project is a non-multi-family residential use, and does not include a common outdoor parking areas, it is exempt from this section. 7-306. TRAIL AND WALKWAY STANDARDS. A multi-modal connection, such as a trail or sidewalk, shall be provided in a development where links to schools, shopping areas, parks, trails, greenbelts, and other public facilities are feasible. N/A. Considering the project parcel’s location and the surrounding land uses, links to schools, shopping areas, parks, trails, greenbelts, and other public facilities are not feasible. DIVISION 11. ADDITIONAL STANDARDS FOR UTILITIES. 7-1101. SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS. A. Signage. All Solar Energy Systems must install signage warning of electrical shock around the perimeter of the system. Signage warning of electrical shock shall be installed around the perimeter of the system. Also see Solar PV plan set for all additional Labeling and Signage. B.Solar Energy Systems, Accessory. 2. Ground-mounted System: a. A ground-mounted system must meet the minimum setbacks of the zone district and shall be located fully within the Building Envelope, if a Building Envelope exists. The ground mounted system does meet all set back requirements. b. The height of the Solar Energy System shall not exceed 15 feet. Height of the ground mounted system is 10ft. c.The total area of the ground-mounted Solar Energy System shall not exceed 10% percent of the lot’s gross area. Total ground mounted area is 0.004997% of the parcel’s 960 acre size. d.Size of the system(s) is limited to less than a combined 15 kW-rated nameplate DC capacity to include equivalent kW measurement of energy for systems other than photovoltaics The size of the system exceeds 15KW which is why we are submitting this administrative review. FORGESOLAR GLARE ANALYSIS Summary of Results Glare with low potential for temporary after-image predicted PV Array Tilt Orient Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare Energy ° ° min hr min hr kWh PV array 1 30.0 180.0 23 0.4 0 0.0 - PV array 2 30.0 180.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 - Total glare received by each receptor; may include duplicate times of glare from multiple reflective surfaces. Receptor Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare min hr min hr OP 1 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 2 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 3 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 4 23 0.4 0 0.0 OP 5 0 0.0 0 0.0 Project: 1708 CR 121 24.8kw Ground Mounted Solar Array Site configuration: 1708 DR 121 Created 08 Jun, 2023 Updated 08 Jun, 2023 Time-step 1 minute Timezone offset UTC-7 Minimum sun altitude 0.0 deg DNI peaks at 1,000.0 W/m Category 10 to 100 kW (1,000 kW / 8 acre limit) Site ID 92457.16271 Ocular transmission coefficient 0.5 Pupil diameter 0.002 m Eye focal length 0.017 m Sun subtended angle 9.3 mrad PV analysis methodology V2 2 Page 1 of 7 */$5(5(3257 Component Data PV Arrays Name: PV array 1 Axis tracking: Fixed (no rotation) Tilt: 30.0° Orientation: 180.0° Rated power: - Panel material: Smooth glass with AR coating Reflectivity: Vary with sun Slope error: correlate with material Vertex Latitude (°) Longitude (°) Ground elevation (ft) Height above ground (ft) Total elevation (ft) 1 39.496124 -107.136961 7363.09 0.00 7363.09 2 39.496122 -107.136784 7364.62 0.00 7364.62 3 39.496070 -107.136792 7363.18 0.00 7363.18 4 39.496072 -107.136969 7362.42 0.00 7362.42 Name: PV array 2 Axis tracking: Fixed (no rotation) Tilt: 30.0° Orientation: 180.0° Rated power: - Panel material: Smooth glass with AR coating Reflectivity: Vary with sun Slope error: correlate with material Vertex Latitude (°) Longitude (°) Ground elevation (ft) Height above ground (ft) Total elevation (ft) 1 39.496039 -107.136972 7361.86 0.00 7361.86 2 39.496045 -107.136789 7362.76 0.00 7362.76 3 39.495993 -107.136792 7361.57 0.00 7361.57 4 39.495995 -107.136969 7360.93 0.00 7360.93 Page 2 of 7 Discrete Observation Point Receptors Name ID Latitude (°)Longitude (°)Elevation (ft)Height (ft) OP 1 1 39.491247 -107.129613 7308.54 0.00 OP 2 2 39.485918 -107.125476 7632.51 0.00 OP 3 3 39.489321 -107.126420 7337.59 0.00 OP 4 4 39.497413 -107.156783 7650.19 0.00 OP 5 5 39.481921 -107.136537 7200.40 0.00 Page 3 of 7 Glare Analysis Results Summary of Results Glare with low potential for temporary after-image predicted PV Array Tilt Orient Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare Energy ° ° min hr min hr kWh PV array 1 30.0 180.0 23 0.4 0 0.0 - PV array 2 30.0 180.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 - Total glare received by each receptor; may include duplicate times of glare from multiple reflective surfaces. Receptor Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare min hr min hr OP 1 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 2 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 3 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 4 23 0.4 0 0.0 OP 5 0 0.0 0 0.0 PV: PV array 1 low potential for temporary after-image Receptor results ordered by category of glare Receptor Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare min hr min hr OP 4 23 0.4 0 0.0 OP 1 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 2 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 3 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 5 0 0.0 0 0.0 Page 4 of 7 PV array 1 and OP 4 Yellow glare: none Green glare: 23 min. PV array 1 and OP 1 No glare found PV array 1 and OP 2 No glare found PV array 1 and OP 3 No glare found PV array 1 and OP 5 No glare found Page 5 of 7 PV: PV array 2 no glare found Receptor results ordered by category of glare Receptor Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare min hr min hr OP 1 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 2 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 3 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 4 0 0.0 0 0.0 OP 5 0 0.0 0 0.0 PV array 2 and OP 1 No glare found PV array 2 and OP 2 No glare found PV array 2 and OP 3 No glare found PV array 2 and OP 4 No glare found PV array 2 and OP 5 No glare found Page 6 of 7 Assumptions Default glare analysis parameters and observer eye characteristics (for reference only): • Analysis time interval: 1 minute • Ocular transmission coefficient: 0.5 • Pupil diameter: 0.002 meters • Eye focal length: 0.017 meters • Sun subtended angle: 9.3 milliradians © Sims Industries d/b/a ForgeSolar, All Rights Reserved. "Green" glare is glare with low potential to cause an after-image (flash blindness) when observed prior to a typical blink response time. "Yellow" glare is glare with potential to cause an after-image (flash blindness) when observed prior to a typical blink response time. Times associated with glare are denoted in Standard time. For Daylight Savings, add one hour. The algorithm does not rigorously represent the detailed geometry of a system; detailed features such as gaps between modules, variable height of the PV array, and support structures may impact actual glare results. However, we have validated our models against several systems, including a PV array causing glare to the air-traffic control tower at Manchester-Boston Regional Airport and several sites in Albuquerque, and the tool accurately predicted the occurrence and intensity of glare at different times and days of the year. Several V1 calculations utilize the PV array centroid, rather than the actual glare spot location, due to algorithm limitations. This may affect results for large PV footprints. Additional analyses of array sub-sections can provide additional information on expected glare. This primarily affects V1 analyses of path receptors. Random number computations are utilized by various steps of the annual hazard analysis algorithm. Predicted minutes of glare can vary between runs as a result. This limitation primarily affects analyses of Observation Point receptors, including ATCTs. Note that the SGHAT/ ForgeSolar methodology has always relied on an analytical, qualitative approach to accurately determine the overall hazard (i.e. green vs. yellow) of expected glare on an annual basis. The analysis does not automatically consider obstacles (either man-made or natural) between the observation points and the prescribed solar installation that may obstruct observed glare, such as trees, hills, buildings, etc. The subtended source angle (glare spot size) is constrained by the PV array footprint size. Partitioning large arrays into smaller sections will reduce the maximum potential subtended angle, potentially impacting results if actual glare spots are larger than the sub-array size. Additional analyses of the combined area of adjacent sub-arrays can provide more information on potential glare hazards. (See previous point on related limitations.) The variable direct normal irradiance (DNI) feature (if selected) scales the user-prescribed peak DNI using a typical clear-day irradiance profile. This profile has a lower DNI in the mornings and evenings and a maximum at solar noon. The scaling uses a clear-day irradiance profile based on a normalized time relative to sunrise, solar noon, and sunset, which are prescribed by a sun-position algorithm and the latitude and longitude obtained from Google maps. The actual DNI on any given day can be affected by cloud cover, atmospheric attenuation, and other environmental factors. The ocular hazard predicted by the tool depends on a number of environmental, optical, and human factors, which can be uncertain. We provide input fields and typical ranges of values for these factors so that the user can vary these parameters to see if they have an impact on the results. The speed of SGHAT allows expedited sensitivity and parametric analyses. The system output calculation is a DNI-based approximation that assumes clear, sunny skies year-round. It should not be used in place of more rigorous modeling methods. Hazard zone boundaries shown in the Glare Hazard plot are an approximation and visual aid based on aggregated research data. Actual ocular impact outcomes encompass a continuous, not discrete, spectrum. Glare locations displayed on receptor plots are approximate. Actual glare-spot locations may differ. Refer to the Help page at www.forgesolar.com/help/ for assumptions and limitations not listed here. Page 7 of 7 FORGESOLAR GLARE ANALYSIS Glare Policy Adherence The following table estimates the policy adherence of this glare analysis according to the 2021 U.S. Federal Aviation Administration Policy: Review of Solar Energy System Projects on Federally-Obligated Airports This policy may require the following criteria be met for solar energy systems on airport property: • No glare of any kind for Air Traffic Control Tower(s) ("ATCT") at cab height. • Default analysis and observer characteristics, including 1-minute time step. ForgeSolar is not affiliated with the U.S. FAA and does not represent or speak officially for the U.S. FAA. ForgeSolar cannot approve or deny projects - results are informational only. Contact the relevant airport and FAA district office for information on policy and requirements. COMPONENT STATUS DESCRIPTION Analysis parameters PASS Analysis time interval and eye characteristics used are acceptable ATCT(s)N/A No ATCT receptors assessed The referenced policy can be read at https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2021-09862 Project: 1708 CR 121 24.8kw Ground Mounted Solar Array Site configuration: 1708 DR 121 Created 08 Jun, 2023 Updated 08 Jun, 2023 Time-step 1 minute Timezone offset UTC-7 Minimum sun altitude 0.0 deg DNI peaks at 1,000.0 W/m Site ID 92457.16271 Ocular transmission coefficient 0.5 Pupil diameter 0.002 m Eye focal length 0.017 m Sun subtended angle 9.3 mrad PV analysis methodology V2 2 Page 1 of 4 Component Data This report includes results for PV arrays and Observation Point ("OP") receptors marked as ATCTs. Components that are not pertinent to the policy, such as routes, flight paths, and vertical surfaces, are excluded. PV Arrays Observation Point ATCT Receptors No ATCT receptors were included in the analysis. Name: PV array 1 Axis tracking: Fixed (no rotation) Tilt: 30.0° Orientation: 180.0° Rated power: - Panel material: Smooth glass with AR coating Reflectivity: Vary with sun Slope error: correlate with material Vertex Latitude (°) Longitude (°) Ground elevation (ft) Height above ground (ft) Total elevation (ft) 1 39.496124 -107.136961 7363.09 0.00 7363.09 2 39.496122 -107.136784 7364.62 0.00 7364.62 3 39.496070 -107.136792 7363.18 0.00 7363.18 4 39.496072 -107.136969 7362.42 0.00 7362.42 Name: PV array 2 Axis tracking: Fixed (no rotation) Tilt: 30.0° Orientation: 180.0° Rated power: - Panel material: Smooth glass with AR coating Reflectivity: Vary with sun Slope error: correlate with material Vertex Latitude (°) Longitude (°) Ground elevation (ft) Height above ground (ft) Total elevation (ft) 1 39.496039 -107.136972 7361.86 0.00 7361.86 2 39.496045 -107.136789 7362.76 0.00 7362.76 3 39.495993 -107.136792 7361.57 0.00 7361.57 4 39.495995 -107.136969 7360.93 0.00 7360.93 Page 2 of 4 Glare Analysis Results Summary of Results No glare predicted PV Array Tilt Orient Annual Green Glare Annual Yellow Glare Energy ° ° min hr min hr kWh PV array 1 30.0 180.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 - PV array 2 30.0 180.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 - No ATCT receptors were included in the analysis. PV: PV array 1 No ATCT receptors assessed. PV: PV array 2 No ATCT receptors assessed. Page 3 of 4 Assumptions Default glare analysis parameters and observer eye characteristics (for reference only): • Analysis time interval: 1 minute • Ocular transmission coefficient: 0.5 • Pupil diameter: 0.002 meters • Eye focal length: 0.017 meters • Sun subtended angle: 9.3 milliradians 2016 © Sims Industries d/b/a ForgeSolar, All Rights Reserved. "Green" glare is glare with low potential to cause an after-image (flash blindness) when observed prior to a typical blink response time. "Yellow" glare is glare with potential to cause an after-image (flash blindness) when observed prior to a typical blink response time. Times associated with glare are denoted in Standard time. For Daylight Savings, add one hour. The algorithm does not rigorously represent the detailed geometry of a system; detailed features such as gaps between modules, variable height of the PV array, and support structures may impact actual glare results. However, we have validated our models against several systems, including a PV array causing glare to the air-traffic control tower at Manchester-Boston Regional Airport and several sites in Albuquerque, and the tool accurately predicted the occurrence and intensity of glare at different times and days of the year. Several V1 calculations utilize the PV array centroid, rather than the actual glare spot location, due to algorithm limitations. This may affect results for large PV footprints. Additional analyses of array sub-sections can provide additional information on expected glare. This primarily affects V1 analyses of path receptors. Random number computations are utilized by various steps of the annual hazard analysis algorithm. Predicted minutes of glare can vary between runs as a result. This limitation primarily affects analyses of Observation Point receptors, including ATCTs. Note that the SGHAT/ ForgeSolar methodology has always relied on an analytical, qualitative approach to accurately determine the overall hazard (i.e. green vs. yellow) of expected glare on an annual basis. The analysis does not automatically consider obstacles (either man-made or natural) between the observation points and the prescribed solar installation that may obstruct observed glare, such as trees, hills, buildings, etc. The subtended source angle (glare spot size) is constrained by the PV array footprint size. Partitioning large arrays into smaller sections will reduce the maximum potential subtended angle, potentially impacting results if actual glare spots are larger than the sub-array size. Additional analyses of the combined area of adjacent sub-arrays can provide more information on potential glare hazards. (See previous point on related limitations.) The variable direct normal irradiance (DNI) feature (if selected) scales the user-prescribed peak DNI using a typical clear-day irradiance profile. This profile has a lower DNI in the mornings and evenings and a maximum at solar noon. The scaling uses a clear-day irradiance profile based on a normalized time relative to sunrise, solar noon, and sunset, which are prescribed by a sun-position algorithm and the latitude and longitude obtained from Google maps. The actual DNI on any given day can be affected by cloud cover, atmospheric attenuation, and other environmental factors. The ocular hazard predicted by the tool depends on a number of environmental, optical, and human factors, which can be uncertain. We provide input fields and typical ranges of values for these factors so that the user can vary these parameters to see if they have an impact on the results. The speed of SGHAT allows expedited sensitivity and parametric analyses. The system output calculation is a DNI-based approximation that assumes clear, sunny skies year-round. It should not be used in place of more rigorous modeling methods. Hazard zone boundaries shown in the Glare Hazard plot are an approximation and visual aid based on aggregated research data. Actual ocular impact outcomes encompass a continuous, not discrete, spectrum. Glare locations displayed on receptor plots are approximate. Actual glare-spot locations may differ. Refer to the Help page at www.forgesolar.com/help/ for assumptions and limitations not listed here. Page 4 of 4