Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1.00 General Application Materials_Part15 564 A-1 Figure A-1. Overview of the Skinner Ridge 10 pad survey area. 565 A-2 Figure A-2. Aerial overview of the Skinner Ridge 10 pad survey area. 566 Appendix B Photographs of the Survey Area 567 568 B-3 Figure B-1. Overview of the proposed Skinner Ridge 10 pad location; view facing southwest from berm. Figure B-2. Overview of the proposed Skinner Ridge 10 pad location; view facing west-southwest from northeast portion of pad. 569 B-4 Figure B-3. Overview of the proposed Skinner Ridge 10 pad location; view facing northeast from western portion of pad. Figure B-4. Overview of the proposed Skinner Ridge 10 pad location; view facing east from western portion of pad. 570 B-5 Figure B-5. Overview of the agricultural ditch (WB01); view facing northwest. Figure B-6. Overview of the agricultural ditch (WB01); view facing southeast. 571 B-6 Figure B-7. Overview of the intermittent stream (WB02); view facing northeast. Figure B-8. Overview of the intermittent stream (WB02); view facing southwest. 572 APPENDIX C Natural Resources Conservation Service Soil Report for the Survey Area 573 574 Hydric Rating by Map Unit—Douglas-Plateau Area, Colorado, Parts of Garfield and Mesa Counties (Skinner Ridge 10 Pad Survey Area) Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey National Cooperative Soil Survey 7/31/2023 Page 1 of 5 43 7 9 8 9 0 43 7 9 9 8 0 43 8 0 0 7 0 43 8 0 1 6 0 43 8 0 2 5 0 43 8 0 3 4 0 43 8 0 4 3 0 43 7 9 9 8 0 43 8 0 0 7 0 43 8 0 1 6 0 43 8 0 2 5 0 43 8 0 3 4 0 43 8 0 4 3 0 729730 729820 729910 730000 730090 730180 730270 730360 730450 730540 729730 729820 729910 730000 730090 730180 730270 730360 730450 730540 39° 32' 34'' N 10 8 ° 1 9 ' 3 6 ' ' W 39° 32' 34'' N 10 8 ° 1 9 ' 1 ' ' W 39° 32' 16'' N 10 8 ° 1 9 ' 3 6 ' ' W 39° 32' 16'' N 10 8 ° 1 9 ' 1 ' ' W N Map projection: Web Mercator Corner coordinates: WGS84 Edge tics: UTM Zone 12N WGS84 0 150 300 600 900Feet 0 50 100 200 300Meters Map Scale: 1:3,880 if printed on A landscape (11" x 8.5") sheet. Soil Map may not be valid at this scale. 575 MAP LEGEND MAP INFORMATION Area of Interest (AOI) Area of Interest (AOI) Soils Soil Rating Polygons Hydric (100%) Hydric (66 to 99%) Hydric (33 to 65%) Hydric (1 to 32%) Not Hydric (0%) Not rated or not available Soil Rating Lines Hydric (100%) Hydric (66 to 99%) Hydric (33 to 65%) Hydric (1 to 32%) Not Hydric (0%) Not rated or not available Soil Rating Points Hydric (100%) Hydric (66 to 99%) Hydric (33 to 65%) Hydric (1 to 32%) Not Hydric (0%) Not rated or not available Water Features Streams and Canals Transportation Rails Interstate Highways US Routes Major Roads Local Roads Background Aerial Photography The soil surveys that comprise your AOI were mapped at 1:24,000. Warning: Soil Map may not be valid at this scale. Enlargement of maps beyond the scale of mapping can cause misunderstanding of the detail of mapping and accuracy of soil line placement. The maps do not show the small areas of contrasting soils that could have been shown at a more detailed scale. Please rely on the bar scale on each map sheet for map measurements. Source of Map: Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey URL: Coordinate System: Web Mercator (EPSG:3857) Maps from the Web Soil Survey are based on the Web Mercator projection, which preserves direction and shape but distorts distance and area. A projection that preserves area, such as the Albers equal-area conic projection, should be used if more accurate calculations of distance or area are required. This product is generated from the USDA-NRCS certified data as of the version date(s) listed below. Soil Survey Area: Douglas-Plateau Area, Colorado, Parts of Garfield and Mesa Counties Survey Area Data: Version 15, Sep 6, 2022 Soil map units are labeled (as space allows) for map scales 1:50,000 or larger. Date(s) aerial images were photographed: Jun 24, 2020—Jul 8, 2020 The orthophoto or other base map on which the soil lines were compiled and digitized probably differs from the background imagery displayed on these maps. As a result, some minor shifting of map unit boundaries may be evident. Hydric Rating by Map Unit—Douglas-Plateau Area, Colorado, Parts of Garfield and Mesa Counties (Skinner Ridge 10 Pad Survey Area) Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey National Cooperative Soil Survey 7/31/2023 Page 2 of 5 576 Hydric Rating by Map Unit Map unit symbol Map unit name Rating Acres in AOI Percent of AOI 28 Cumulic Haploborolls, 1 to 3 percent slopes 0 0.0 0.0% 44 Happle very channery sandy loam, 3 to 12 percent slopes 0 22.4 56.0% 46 Happle-Rock outcrop association, 25 to 65 percent slopes 0 14.1 35.2% 67 Tosca channery loam, 25 to 80 percent slopes MLRA 48A 0 3.5 8.8% Totals for Area of Interest 40.0 100.0% Hydric Rating by Map Unit—Douglas-Plateau Area, Colorado, Parts of Garfield and Mesa Counties Skinner Ridge 10 Pad Survey Area Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey National Cooperative Soil Survey 7/31/2023 Page 3 of 5 577 ECMC – CPW – Deer Park Gulch Spor�ish Management Waters High Priority Habitat Rule Waiver Request 578 Chevron Rockies Business Unit 2001 16th Street, Ste 900 Denver, Colorado, 80220 Energy and Carbon Management Commission- Colorado Parks and Wildlife- Deer Park Gulch Sportfish Management Waters High Priority Habitat Rule Waiver Request Pursuant to the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission (ECMC) 1200 Series Rules for the protection of wildlife and habitat, Chevron USA Inc. (Chevron) is presenting this request to ECMC and Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW) for consideration of the following for the SKR 698-10-BV OGDP. CPW Northwest Energy Liaison Taylor Elm, reviewed and approved this waiver request document on 11/16/23. Mr. Elm’s approval email is attached to the OGDP submittal. •Waiver to Rule 1202.c.(1).S. (waiver under 309.e.(5).ii) “For Perennial Streams, if the Operator adheres to the following Best Management Practices for any new ground disturbance that meets the criteria of Rule 1202.c. between 300 feet and 500 feet from the OHWM of Sportfish Management Waters” •Waiver to Rule 1202.a.(3) “At new and existing Oil and Gas Locations, Operators will not situate new staging, refueling or Chemical storage areas within 500 feet of the Ordinary High-Water Mark (OHWM) of any river, perennial or intermittent stream, lake pond or wetland” •Review and acceptance of Rule 1202.c.(2).C: “Access road construction and Flowline/utility corridor clearing and installation activities within the High Priority Habitat identified in Rules 1202.c.(1).Q–S in association with an approved Form 2A may be allowed subject to Best Management Practices or other avoidance measures agreed to in consultation with CPW” Chevron is proposing the use of an existing pad in our SKR 698-10-BV OGDP for the drilling and completion of up to two wells on the SKR 698-10-BV pad located within T6S, R98W, Section 15 (NW/NW) and Section 10 (SW/SW), Garfield County, Colorado (Figure 1). The proposed drilling unit is delineated below in red and the drill pad is located in the southwest corner of the drilling unit. 579 November 16, 2023 Page 2 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 1- SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad The drill pad location, although permitted for oil and gas development under O&G Location ID Number 336056, was never developed for well drilling and has been utilized as an equipment/material storage yard permitted by Garfield County. Due to the optimal proximity of the SKR 698-10-BV pad at the southwestern extent of the proposed drill unit, use of the existing pad would eliminate any additional pad construction disturbances outside of the pad’s original Disturbed Area (DA) and allow well drilling and completion activities, with gas takeaway already in-place adjacent to the proposed pad. The extent of the proposed activities would include well drilling and completion, freshwater sourcing from the Colorado River, gas and water flowline tie-in, emergency access road construction, and produced water flowback management and water hauling activities. Source water for drilling and completion activities will be pumped from the Kobe Water Facility and along a federal Right-of-Way (ROW) evaluated and approved by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) in 2023 for well completion activities in Skinner Ridge, initiated in August 2023. The temporary ROW authorization (COC-80860) is good for a three-year term and will be utilized for Chevron’s well drilling under this project. The temporary source water flowline will include approximately 12 miles of surface flat-lay flowline and pump stations along existing water diversion and access road disturbances, up to the water staging pad and SKR 698-10-BV well pad. Well drilling and completion activities are all potentially within 500 feet of Deer Park Gulch (also known as Tom Creek), a Rule 1202.c.(1).S. defined Sportfish Management Waters High Priority Habitat (HPH) presented as Figure 2. Chevron personnel consulted with Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW’s) Northwest Region Energy Liaison, Taylor Elm, in early 2023 to discuss the proposed project. CPW reviewed proposed activities and agreed that use of existing disturbances for the project was preferable and requested that Chevron provide this formal request for Waiver to these activities in HPH. 580 November 16, 2023 Page 3 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 2- SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad adjacent to Deer Park Gulch (aka Tom Creek) Anticipated activities include the following: • Drilling and completion of up to two wells on the SKR 698-10-BV well pad; well completion activities will require the staging of flowback tanks and equipment and construction of a temporary freshwater storage facility (MLVT) on the SKR 22-1 pad to the south (the Skinner Ridge 66S98W/22NENW pad; Location ID# 324358, aka SKR 22-1). 581 November 16, 2023 Page 4 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 • Gas and liquids production flowline tie-in at Clear Creek Road immediately adjacent to the SKR 698-10-BV pad for gas, and then liquids flowline installed up to the SKR 698-09 AV Pad (Figure 3). FIGURE 3- Liquids (Red) and Gas (Yellow) Flowline Tie-in; SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad to the SKR 698-09-AV Well Pad • Construction of a secondary access road at the southwest corner of the SKR 698-10-BV pad. • Temporary installation of a surface-lay freshwater feed line to MLVT staging at the SKR 22-1 pad, and then fresh water supply line routing to the SKR 598-36-BV well pad to support well completion activities (Figure 4). 582 November 16, 2023 Page 5 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 4- Fresh Water Sourcing from the SKR 22-1 Pad to the SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad Waiver to Rule 1202.c.(1).S. As documented in the SKR 698-10-BV OGDP Application, Chevron pre-consulted with CPW pursuant to the need for a request to the Commission for approval of a Rule 502 Variance as it relates to Rule 1202.c(1).S. (i.e., Sportfish management waters not identified by CPW as “Gold Medal” (within 500 feet of OHWM)). Although the Commission is empowered to grant a Variance “to any of the Commission’s Rules or orders . . . after a hearing upon the application.” Rule 502.b.(1), CPW Northwest Energy liaison Taylor Elm reviewed the SKR 698-10-BV location and determined that although the location does 583 November 16, 2023 Page 6 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 fall within Rule 1202.c.(1).S. HPH, the applicability of waiver provisions of Rule 309.e.(5).D.ii.bb would be appropriate to Deer Park Gulch and this OGDP application. ii. CPW may waive the application of and the Director may grant an exception to Rule 1202.c.(1).S: bb. For ephemeral and intermittent streams, if the Operator adheres to the following Best Management Practices: 1. Contain Flowback and Stimulation Fluids in Tanks that are placed on a Working Pad Surface in an area with downgradient perimeter berming; 2. Construct lined berms or other lined containment devices pursuant to Rule 603.o around any new crude oil, condensate, and produced water storage Tanks that are installed after January 15, 2021; 3. Inspect the Oil and Gas Location on a daily basis, unless the approved Form 2A provides for different inspection frequency or alternative method of compliance; 4. Maintain adequate Spill response equipment at the Oil and Gas Location during drilling and completion operations; and 5. Not construct or utilize any Pits, except that Operators may continue to utilize exiting Pits that were properly permitted, constructed, operated, and maintained in compliance prior to January 15, 2021. Therefore, this Rule provision allows for CPW to grant a waiver for an intermittent drainage anywhere within the 500-foot Aquatic HPH buffer area, instead of within 300 to 500 feet of the OHWM, as would be the case if Deer Park Gulch were a perennial drainage. Chevron respectfully requests that CPW/ECMC provide a Waiver to the rule and the 500-foot NSO and grant an application allowing these proposed activities to occur within 0-500 feet from the Sportfish Management Waters OHWM (Figure 2). Further, Chevron has made a good faith effort to comply with Commission Rules, as well as the spirit of the Commission’s rule and the requested Waiver will not violate the basic intent of the Act under the following conditions and Best Management Practices (BMPs). • Chevron proposes to utilize an existing and established disturbance under this Waiver which eliminates the impact from new pad construction, is protective of public health, safety, welfare, the environment, and wildlife resources and contains mitigation measures (as BMPs) to avoid, minimize, or mitigate any adverse impacts. The gas flowline takeaway tie-in and proposed emergency pad access construction are immediately adjacent to the SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad and Clear Creek Road and will require minimal to no expansion of disturbances (Figure 5). 584 November 16, 2023 Page 7 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 5- SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad, Drilling/Completion Stage 585 November 16, 2023 Page 8 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 • The requested Waiver implements design mitigation measures protective of Aquatic Sportfish Management Waters associated with Deer Park Gulch, and include: o Stormwater management design protections that include a perimeter collection channel around the entire pad circumference while routing stormwater flow to two dedicated detention ponds on the south and west sides of the pad. o Post interim reclamation will maintain diversion channels on the south and west side of the reclaimed pad area to route surface flows to the permanent sediment pond(s). o Interim reclamation for long-term well production and facility operation will reduce the original location disturbed area (DA) from 6.4 acres to 1.7 acres, re- establishing approximately 4.6 acres of habitat to the area (Figure 6). o The post-interim reclamation facility pad area will include a permanent raised berm between the facility maintenance tank and Deer Park Gulch. o The facility maintenance tank will be constructed within an impervious, geosynthetic-lined under base, anchored into a metal-sided secondary containment system capable of containing up to 50% of the tank capacity and any spill or leak from the storage vessel. o Telemetric and automation technology will be utilized to monitor any variations in facility pressures and fluid gauges which could indicate a leak and provide remote shut-in capabilities of the facility in the event of any discharge or emergency. o A dedicated Spill-Response trailer with spill containment equipment will be staged full time at the SKR 698-10-BV well pad throughout well drilling activities and well completion operations. o The proposed activities will not utilize any pits. Fresh water will be temporarily stored in the Harpoon MLVT (Modular Large Volume Tank) structure on the SKR 22-1 pad, which will be covered to protect wildlife and treated for WNV larvae. o The location with be inspected daily during long-term production activities. 586 November 16, 2023 Page 9 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 6- SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad, Post Interim Reclamation 587 November 16, 2023 Page 10 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 This Waiver request can be further substantiated by the typical hydrologic conditions within the Clear Creek drainage system and specifically Deer Park Gulch. Based on the ephemeral flow conditions of the Roan Creek drainage system, SWCA Environmental Consultants (SWCA) performed field analysis of Deer Park Gulch (aka Tom Creek) on behalf of Chevron in July 2023. SWCA field determined that the Deer Park Gulch drainage’s seasonal flow (Figure 7) would be incapable of supporting sportfish species, had a shallow and inconsistent OHWM, could not support any fringe wetlands within the survey area , and by definition the SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad does not fall within any mapped habitat triggering consultation under Rule 1202.c. The full SWCA field analysis is attached to this Waiver request. FIGURE 7- Deer Park Gulch, approximately 180 feet East of the Proposed Pad Further, water flow within the Roan Creek drainage (of which Deer Park Gulch, tributary to Clear Creek, is just one of many tributaries) is monitored at the De Beque flow monitoring station approximately 13 miles downstream from the SKR 698-10-BV drill pad and Chevron’s proposed activities. Flow from USGS Station 391953108130201 (2022 flows shown below as Figure 8) indicate that cumulative flows from the entire Roan Creek contributory system can range between less than one cubic feet per second (cfs) and up to 40 cfs sustained flows, with transitory storm event peaks up to 100 cfs or more. However, sustained flows over the entire drainage system between one and ten cfs would not appear to support Sportfish Management Species long term. Consequently, Clear Creek and Deer Park Gulch, would contribute just a fraction of these flow volumes to the Roan Creek system and would therefore not appear to be able to sustain aquatic species. 588 November 16, 2023 Page 11 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 FIGURE 8- USGS Station at De Beque, Colorado Chevron is aware of CPW’s designation of Deer Park Gulch/Clear Creek as Sportfish Management Waters 1202.c HPH and respectfully requests this Exception request to Rule 502.b.(1) (between 0’-300’ from the OHWM) and Waiver request per Rule 309.e.(5).D consultation for well drilling, completion, flowback and water recycle activities in protection of the HPH (between 300’-500’ from the OHWM). Rule 1202.a.(3) Waiver Request Chevron respectfully requests a waiver to Rule 1202.a.(3) for long term placement of tanks within 500 feet of Deer Park Gulch supported by the following hydrologic review and BMP commitment. Field Hydrologic Review Hydrologic field review of the SKR 698-10-BV project was performed by SWCA Environmental Services Professional Wetland Scientist (PWS) the week of July 21st, 2023. Survey activities were performed based on existing hydrologic features identified in the field including National Wetland Inventory (NWI)-mapped wetlands, National Hydrography Dataset (NHD) delineations, and the features presented on the SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad Hydrology Map to be submitted with the 2A application packet to ECMC. As depicted on Figure 9, SWCA confirmed that Deer Park Gulch (dry at the time of inspection) which can seasonally hold water and has a defined OHWM is identified as Sportfish Management Waters HPH and is located ±150’ southeast of the pad’s permitted 589 November 16, 2023 Page 12 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 disturbed area (DA). Also, an agricultural ditch (holding water at the time of inspection) was identified ±343’ southwest of the pad’s DA. No other associated wetlands, water features or hydrophytic plant or soil indicators were identified within 500 feet of the pad’s DA. FIGURE 9- SKR 698-10-BV Well Pad Hydrologic Review The recent hydrology field investigation suggests that per Rule 1202.a.(3), long -term well and facility operations will place the maintenance tank in the northeast portion of the pad (refer to Figure 6) within 500 feet of Deer Park Gulch to the southeast and the agricultural ditch to the southwest. Chevron is requesting CPW Waiver approval to Rule 1202.a.(3) for this location in protection of these potential aquatic resources. Chevron commits to institute the following BMPs to be protective of Deer Park Gulch and the agricultural ditch: o The facility maintenance tank (example picture below) will be constructed within an impervious, geosynthetic-lined under base, anchored into a metal-sided secondary containment system capable of containing up to 50% of the tanks capacity and any spill or leak from the storage vessel; 590 November 16, 2023 Page 13 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 o Interim reclamation of the pad will include a permanent berm placed downgradient from - the maintenance tank and between the maintenance tank and Deer Park Gulch ; o Permanent, post-interim reclamation stormwater controls will route flow from the facility area to perimeter collection channels and to stormwater sediment ponds located between the pad and downgradient aquatic features; o All surficial activities performed by Chevron during production operation activities will be protective of the environment. All vessels, totes, valves and flow lines associated with well production activities will be inspected daily for damage or leaks while in service; o Telemetric and automation technology will be utilized to monitor any variations in facility pressures and fluid gauges which could indicate a leak and provide remote shut-in capabilities of the facility in the event of any discharge or emergency ; and The complete Hydrologic Survey Report for the SKR 698-10-BV Pad is attached to this Waiver document. Chevron respectfully requests a timely review of the project by CPW and that a Waiver to Rule 1202.a.(3) be approved. Review and acceptance of Rule 1202.c.(2).C. The construction of a production flowline for liquids transfer between the SKR 698-10-BV drill pad and SKR 698-09-AV drill pad (Figure 10, red trace) is proposed in anticipation of gas and liquid delivery to the Skinner Ridge gas processing facility approximately 2 ½ miles Northwest of the SKR 698-10-BV pad, along Clear Creek Road. Gas flowline tie-in (Figure 10, yellow trace) will require a short 90-foot lateral travelling west of the SKR 698-10-BV pad to an existing gas-gathering line adjacent to Clear Creek Road. Although approximately ½ of the liquid flowline (2500 feet with an overall length of 4900 feet) will require disturbances within Clear Creek’s Aquatic Sportfish 591 November 16, 2023 Page 14 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 Management Waters NSO, the gathering lines will be within the existing flowline right-of-way (ROW) along Clear Creek Road and Chevron respectfully utilizes Rule 1202.c.(2).C where: Access road construction and Flowline/utility corridor clearing and installation activities within the High Priority Habitat identified in Rules 1202.c.(1).Q –S in association with an approved Form 2A may be allowed subject to Best Management Practices or other avoidance measures agreed to in consultation with CPW FIGURE 10- SKR 698-10-BV Gas and Liquid Gathering Lines Per Chevron’s ongoing communication with CPW, Taylor Elm indicated that CPW concurs with the application of Rule 1202.c.(2).C. to allow for flowline installation within the aquatic habitat buffer . Chevron commits to institute the following BMPs to be protective of Clear Creek and its associated fringe wetlands during flowline installation. 592 November 16, 2023 Page 15 of 15 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado 80202 1. The liquids flowline alignment will be constructed within the existing flowline ROW where the existing gas gathering flowline was installed. Flowline installation methods will provide a natural upgradient stormwater barrier to any siltation, fluid discharge or stormwater flow West toward Clear Creek. 2. Stormwater controls such as straw wattles and/or silt fencing will be utilized along the flowline alignment to contain any off-disturbance flow or soil movement during flowline installation. 3. Sediment settling areas (ponds) will be established within any existing access road runoff ditch. 4. The flowline will be Inspected daily during installation operations. 5. Following flowline installation, the disturbance will be covered, regraded, topsoil replaced, and reseeded as quickly as possible. 6. A dedicated Spill-Response trailer with spill containment equipment will be staged full time at the SKR 698-10-BV pad throughout flowline installation activities. Elk Winter Concentration Area HPH Rule 1202.d.(2) In addition to Sportfish Management Waters HPH, Chevron’s proposed well drilling and completion project lies within Elk Winter Concentration Area HPH, pursuant to Rule 1202.d.(2). Chevron has consulted directly with CPW per this resource and will attempt to perform all construction, well drilling and completion activities outside of the protective timing stipulation for this habitat (i.e., allowed between May 1 thru November 30). Should proposed activities outlined in this document be delayed or the potential exists that work may extend into this protective timing window, prior to any further activity Chevron will re-consult with CPW and determine if a waiver to the timing stipulation is appropriate, along with any BMPs required to protect the species and habitat. Chevron appreciates ECMC’s and CPW’s review and consideration of these waiver requests. Please don’t hesitate to contact me directly if either agency requires additional information or clarification for their determination. Michael Keller- Lead Environmental Specialist Cc: Derek Eggert . Mike Rodine Michael Jewell 593 CPW Approval Documenta�on for Deer Park Gulch Spor�ish Management Waters High Priority Habitat Rule Waiver Request 594 From:Taylor Elm - DNR To:Keller, Michael Subject:[**EXTERNAL**] Re: Draft for consultation- Skinner Ridge 698-10-BV Well Pad and Sportfish Management Waters HPH Waiver Request Date:Thursday, November 16, 2023 10:57:41 AM Be aware this external email contains an attachment and/or link. Ensure the email and contents are expected. If there are concerns, please submit suspicious messages to the Cyber Intelligence Center using the Report Phishing button. Mike, Thank you for the continued communication on this matter and for incorporating the suggested edits that I had provided on October 25th. Based on those changes and the pre-application consultation process we've been engaged in, CPW approves both of the waivers being requested (Rule 1202.c.(1).S. NSO stipulation and Rule 1202.a.(3).). We appreciate Chevron's thorough investigation of the Deer Park Gulch waterway and we agree with the results of the SWCA Consulting report. This drainage does not contain sufficient year-round flows to support any sportfish populations. Additionally, we appreciate the incorporation of the best management practices that we have discussed to further minimize adverse impacts related to these two waiver requests. Based on these factors, CPW does not have significant concerns related to the proposed oil and gas activities. We approve both waiver requests, and consider this email correspondence as our official waiver approval. If you have any questions, or we can provide additional information, please don't hesitate to reach out. Thank you, Taylor Elm Northwest Region Energy Liaison P 970.947.2971 | C 970.986.9767 711 Independent Ave. Grand Junction, CO 81505 taylor.elm@state.co.us | cpw.state.co.us On Tue, Oct 24, 2023 at 3:22 PM Keller, Michael <michael.keller@chevron.com> wrote: Hi Taylor and I hope you are well. Please see the attached Draft of our proposed Waiver Request for Skinner Ridge well drilling/completions and flowline installation near/within the Deer Park Gulch/Clear Creek Aquatic Sportfish Management Waters HPH. As we discussed, I cited Rule 309.e.(5).D.ii.bb to role the ECMC Variance request into CPW purview and Waiver approval. Just an FYI, Figure 5 and Figure 6 (grading plan drawings are just draft and a little difficult to see; those will be replaced with final drawings. This will be submitted with the WMP and 2A packet, and I wanted your eyes on it first. I appreciate your guidance and review of the document as part of our consultation effort with CPW. Thanks Taylor. Mike. 595 Variance to Rule 1202.c.(1).S roll this into CPWs waiver below Waiver to Rule 1202.c.(1).S. Waiver to Rule 1202.a.(3) staging chemical storage within 500’ of an aquatic resource Review and acceptance of Rule 1202.c.(2).C allowing flowline construction within aquatic HPH Michael Keller Lead Environmental Specialist Michael.Keller@Chevron.com Chevron Rockies Business Unit Chevron Corporation 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado, 80202 Mobile 970-415-2631 596 From:Taylor Elm - DNR To:Keller, Michael Subject:[**EXTERNAL**] Re: Draft for consultation- Skinner Ridge 698-10-BV Well Pad and Sportfish Management Waters HPH Waiver Request Date:Wednesday, October 25, 2023 10:40:27 AM Be aware this external email contains an attachment and/or link. Ensure the email and contents are expected. If there are concerns, please submit suspicious messages to the Cyber Intelligence Center using the Report Phishing button. Hello Mike, Thanks for sending over this draft document. I think the bulk of the document and justification pieces (i.e., BMPs being implemented, hydrologic data that has been gathered, etc.) all look really good. I don't have any edits or additional measures that CPW would like to see included. One recommendation on the first page would be to remove the "Variance to Rule 1202.c.(1).S." section entirely, as there is not any ECMC variance needed. Instead I would only include the Rule 309.e. (5).D.ii.bb CPW waiver request as you mentioned, and remove the "for perennial streams" language in the second section. This is not the instance that we're addressing, so I would clean all that up to be very clear on the waiver request being submitted. Also, small potatoes, but on PDF page 13 I'd recommend the following change: Per Chevron’s ongoing communication with CPW, Taylor Elm indicated that CPW concurs with the application of Rule 1202.c.(2).C. to allow for flowline installation within the aquatic habitat buffer could grant this waiver. Chevron commits to institute the following BMPs to be protective of Clear Creek and its associated fringe wetlands during flowline installation. Our concurrence on the application of Rule 1202.c.(2).C. is not typically necessary, but I'm happy to provide that. I just want to be clear that this is not a "waiver" that CPW is granting, it's allowed per that rule. We tend to catch flak for allowing so many waivers, so if we can avoid the perception of granting another one, it helps! Thanks, On Tue, Oct 24, 2023 at 3:22 PM Keller, Michael <michael.keller@chevron.com> wrote: Hi Taylor and I hope you are well. Please see the attached Draft of our proposed Waiver Request for Skinner Ridge well drilling/completions and flowline installation near/within the Deer Park Gulch/Clear Creek Aquatic Sportfish Management Waters HPH. As we discussed, I cited Rule 309.e.(5).D.ii.bb to role the ECMC Variance request into CPW purview and Waiver approval. Just an FYI, Figure 5 and Figure 6 (grading plan drawings are just draft and a little difficult to see; those will be replaced with final drawings. This will be submitted with the WMP and 2A packet, and I wanted your eyes on it first. I appreciate your guidance and review of the document as part of our consultation effort with CPW. Thanks Taylor. Mike. 597 Variance to Rule 1202.c.(1).S roll this into CPWs waiver below Waiver to Rule 1202.c.(1).S. Waiver to Rule 1202.a.(3) staging chemical storage within 500’ of an aquatic resource Review and acceptance of Rule 1202.c.(2).C allowing flowline construction within aquatic HPH Michael Keller Lead Environmental Specialist Michael.Keller@Chevron.com Chevron Rockies Business Unit Chevron Corporation 2001 16th Street, Suite 900 Denver, Colorado, 80202 Mobile 970-415-2631 598 WATER PLAN Date: 11/10/2023 Location: OGDP SKR 698-10-BV / SKR 698-10-BV Pad Legal Description: Tract 72, SWSW of Section 10 & NWNW of Section 15, Township 6 South, Range 98 West, 6th P.M., Garfield County, Colorado 599 Location Information This document provides site-specific information for the SKR 698-10-BV Pad. The information in this document relates specifically to the time during the construction, drilling, completion, and production of the two (2) proposed horizontal wells on the well pad portion of the location, and the construction and operation of the facility portion of the location, which will receive production from the two wells. Additionally, a pilot hole for geothermal testing will be drilled in one of the wells, but the pilot hole will be plugged back prior to drilling the horizontal leg of the well. The existing location is located off Garfield County Road 211 (Clear Creek Road) approximately 16.7 miles northwest of De Beque, Colorado. The Pad lies on Tract 72, and is situated on two sections, the SWSW of Section 10 and the NWNW of Section 15, Township 6 South, Range 98 West, 6th P.M. zoned Resource Lands per Garfield County. Water Sources Source Details Ahead of completion activity, construction and drilling activities will utilize additional, but significantly smaller, water volumes. Typically, these water volumes are supplied independently of the completion water sources and may be trucked to location. Various water sources may be used for construction and drilling; sources will be selected based upon limiting trucking distance and minimizing adverse impacts related to construction and drilling activities. Table 1 below presents potential drilling and construction water source types, volumes, and locations. Table 1: Construction and Drilling Sources - SKR 698-10-BV Pad Source Name Source Type Latitude Longitude Est. Volume (BBLs) Transport Method Chevron Skinner Ridge Freshwater Pond Surface Water 39.572450°N 108.347722°W 4,000 Trucked Below are the seller’s name and address of water sources planned for construction and drilling: Chevron Skinner Ridge Freshwater Pond Chevron Ranch Headquarters 8311 County Road 215 Parachute, Colorado 81635 All freshwater for downhole frac operations will be moved by pipeline to minimize risks to public health, safety, environment, and wildlife. Temporary infrastructure will be constructed as needed to convey water sources to the Pad for development activities. Planned water source types, volumes, and locations are summarized below in Table 2. 600 Table 2: Completion Source - SKR 698-10-BV Pad Source Name Source Type Latitude Longitude Est. Volume (BBLs) Transport Method West Divide Water Conservancy District Surface Water 39.366553°N 108.257089°W 1,440,000 Piped Below are the seller’s name and address of water sources planned for completions: West Divide Water Conservancy District P. O. Box 1478 818 Taughenbaugh Blvd., #101 Rifle, CO 81650 Water Recycling or Re-Use The use of recycled produced water at the SKR 698-10-BV Pad is not planned due to the lack of existing infrastructure and extensive distance between the location and existing recycled water sources. Chevron is dedicated to increasing recycled water usage and will continue to explore opportunities to utilize recycled water at the Pad. 601 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 1 Cumulative Impacts CUMULATIVE IMPACTS PLAN Date: November 29, 2023 Location: OGDP SKR 698-10-BV Development Area Legal Description (Garfield County, CO): Township 6 South, Range 98 West, 6th P.M. Section 3: Part of Lot 5 and Tracts 38, 48B, 49, 58, and 107 Section 10: Part of Lots 1, 3, 4, and Tracts 72, 45, 46, 48B, 49, 50 Section 15: Part of Tract 72 Township 5 South, Range 97 West, 6th P.M. Section 31: Part of Lots 9, 10, 11, and Tract 58 This Cumulative Impacts Plan has been prepared in accordance with the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission (ECMC or Commission) Rule 304.c.(19) and follows the resources analyzed for potential cumulative impacts pursuant to Rule 303.a.(5). The Plan provides an overview of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV Project, specifically the proposed drilling, completion and production of two wells on the existing SKR 698-10-BV Pad and the methodology used for determining cumulative impacts. Finally, the Plan also includes the following sections, as prescribed in Rule 304.c.(19): Resources Impacted (Section 3.0) – A description of all resources to which cumulative adverse impacts are expected to be increased; Minimization Measures (Section 4.0) – A description of specific measures taken to avoid or minimize the extent to which cumulative adverse impacts are increased; Mitigation Measures (Section 5.0) – A description of all measures taken to mitigate or offset cumulative adverse impacts to any of the resources; and Additional Information (Sections 1.0 and 2.0) – Information determined to be reasonable and necessary to the evaluation of cumulative impacts by the Operator, the Director, CDPHE, CPW, or the Relevant Local Government. 1.0 Project Overview This document provides site-specific information for OGDP SKR 698-10-BV. The information in this document relates specifically to the time during the construction, drilling, completion, and production of the two proposed horizontal wells in this OGDP. The proposed location is an existing well pad in rangeland adjacent to Garfield County Road 211 (CR 211) approximately 4.1 miles north of CR 204. A pre-application conference with Garfield County was held on October 12, 2023, and was attended by representatives from Garfield County, ECMC, CPW, CDPHE, and Chevron. Based on input from CDPHE staff during the pre-application conference, a pre-application consultation with CDPHE staff was not held for this project. CDPHE will determine whether formal consultation will be required when the OGDP has been deemed complete by ECMC. 602 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 2 Cumulative Impacts The two proposed wells on this location will produce to initial production equipment located on the well pad. The equipment at the well pad will include separators, pigging stations, a gas meter, pipe skid, an instrument air skid, a skid drain vault, a chemical injection skid, a communication tower, solar skids, a maintenance tank, heat trace equipment, a transformer or electric generators, switchracks, and a battery box. Liquids (condensate/oil and water) and natural gas produced from these wells will be transported via underground pipelines to Chevron’s existing Central Production Facility (CPF) for additional processing. Condensate/oil and natural gas will be transferred to midstream assets at the CPF and produced water will be transported to an existing, permitted disposal well via an underground pipeline. 1.1 Surface Disturbance Construction associated with the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV Pad will be minimal and associated with an additional access road, flowlines, and drainage basins. This construction would result in an estimated initial disturbance of 16.4 acres (including existing and new disturbance) and long-term disturbance of 2.4 acres. Initial and long-term disturbance by project feature is summarized in Table 1. Site reclamation would be initiated for portions of the well pad not required for the continued operation of the well within six months of completion, weather permitting. Table 1 Estimated Surface Disturbance Project Feature Initial (acres) Long-Term (acres)1 Well Pad 6.9 2.3 Existing Disturbance 6.2 New Disturbance 0.7 New Access Road Corridors 0.1 0.1 Flowline Corridors 9.5 0 OGDP Total 16.4 2.4 1 Residual disturbance calculations are based on the assumption that interim reclamation would be successful. As documented in the Alternative Location Analysis (ALA) submitted with this OGDP, Chevron analyzed alternative locations for the proposed well pad, however, none of these alternative locations resulted in reduced impact. It is difficult, if not impossible, to find alternative locations that are outside of HPH or a DI community, and all alternative locations would result in new and increased surface disturbance. The use of the existing well pad minimizes surface disturbance to the maximum extent possible, and interim reclamation of this well pad will result in the disturbance being reduced by approximately 3.8 acres from what has been in use for the storage yard. Although the existing SKR 698-10-BV Pad can safely accommodate the proposed drilling and completions operations, it is smaller than what Chevron would consider as an ideal size for these operations; therefore, the use of the existing pad res ults in approximately 1.5 acres less of disturbance than would occur if a new pad was constructed. Additionally, most alternative locations would require significantly more disturbance for construction of access roads and flowlines. 2.0 Cumulative Impact Methodology Cumulative impacts on the environment may result when the environmental effects associated with a proposed project are added to other past, current, and reasonably foreseeable future 603 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 3 Cumulative Impacts actions. Cumulative impacts can result from individually minor but collectively significant actions taking place over a period of time. The proposed OGDP SKR 698-10-BV is within an area of existing oil and gas development, and is surrounded by agricultural operations in Garfield County, Colorado. Most of the past, present, and reasonably foreseeable development in the vicinity of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV is associated with current or planned oil and gas exploration, midstream infrastructure, and agricultural development. This area is very sparsely populated and the nearest RBU to the SKR 69 -10-BV Pad is over one mile to the south. The only occupied buildings near the well pad are associated with Chevron’s field office approximately 830 feet to the northwest. Information for this cumulative impact assessment was obtained from county, state, and federal websites, and other public domain sources. Specifically, the existing SKR 698 -10-BV Pad has approximately 7 oil and gas locations considered “active” within a 1-mile radius to the ECMC location files online. To provide information relevant to ECMC decision making, a practical delineation of the spatial and temporal scales is needed for an informative cumulative impacts’ analysis. The geographic extent of each specific Cumulative Impact Analysis Area (CIAA) varies by resource and is larger for resources that are mobile or migrate, as compared to those that are stationary. For some resources, the CIAA is smaller due to the geographically confined nature of cumulative impacts (e.g., vegetation), while for others the CIAA is much larger (e.g., air quality). Table 2 provides the geographic extent for cumulative impact analysis that was applied for the OGDP SKR 698- 10-BV location. For most resources, the temporal boundary is assumed to be the 30-year life of production. For wildlife and vegetation, the temporal boundary is extended an additional 5 years to account for the time required to reach 75-100 percent reclamation. Table 2 Geographic Scope for Cumulative Impact Analysis Environmental Resource Cumulative Impact Assessment Area (CIAA) Air Quality 1-mile radius Public Health 1-mile radius Water Resources ½-mile radius Terrestrial and Aquatic Wildlife Resources and Ecosystems 1-mile radius (specifically High Priority Habitats [HPH] within 1-mile) Soil Resources Limits of disturbance for the location (including access roads and pipeline rights-of-ways [ROWs]) Vegetation 1-mile radius Public Welfare – Noise, Odor, Light 1-mile radius 3.0 Resources Impacted The following section describes the resources for which cumulative impacts are anticipated, based on the information included on the Form 2B and the site-specific plans associated with Form 2A. 3.1 Air Resources and Public Health1 Air quality in an area is generally influenced by the quantities of pollutants that are released within and upwind of the area, and it can be highly dependent upon the pollutants’ chemical and 604 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 4 Cumulative Impacts physical properties. Air quality regulations and source-specific permits limit the allowable quantities of pollutants that may be emitted. The topography, weather, and land use in an area will also affect how pollutants are transported and dispersed and the resulting ambient concentrations. The location of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV and broader CIAA currently contains various emission sources including agricultural fields, vehicle traffic, and oil and gas production and infrastructure. Most notably, there are no Residential Building Units (RBUs) within over 1 mile from the Working Pad Surface (WPS) of the SKR 698-10-BV Pad. The addition of the infrastructure needed to construct, drill, and operate the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location would have a cumulative impact on air quality within the 1- mile CIAA. However, the proposed wells’ contribution to cumulative effects would be minor, as demonstrated by the Emissions Inventory results reflected in Form 2B, and modeling assessment results from the October 17, 2019 Final Report: Human Health Risk Assessment for Oil & Gas Operations in Colorado published by CDPHE. The Air Resources impacts would be minimized and mitigated by the measures included in Sections 4 and 5 of this Cumulative Impacts Plan. Emissions would be permitted and regulated by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Air Pollution Control Division, and would be subject to appropriate controls to reduce emissions to minimal levels. However, in the context of cumulative impact assessment, any contribution to emissions, no matter how small, adds to the cumulative effects from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future projects. 3.2 Water Resources There are no public water system intakes located within a mile of the proposed OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location. Construction of oil and gas facilities and associated infrastructure and industrial development would likely have the greatest potential impact on water resources within the ½-mile radius CIAA due to the potential for increased erosion and sedimentation rates. Soils compacted on existing roads, new access roads, and well pads contribute to slightly greater runoff than undisturbed sites. Increased erosion and subsequent increased sedimentation of intermittent streams and ephemeral drainages within the CIAA is possible, especially during construction and other surface disturbing activities. These effects could have negative impacts on aquatic habitat within affected drainages. To assess the potential of impacts to water resources, Chevron utilizes several different sources of information and field surveys to verify the location and nature of hydrologic features. The Hydrology Map included in the Form 2A submittal for this pad reflects the compilation of information available from a variety of public sources and limited information from land surveyors employed by Chevron. Chevron also utilizes the services of a third- party environmental consultant to conduct aquatic resources inventories and the results of these inventories are documented in the Aquatic Resources Inventory Report (ARIR) attached to the Wildlife Mitigation Plan included in the Form 2A submittal. This ARIR documents the results of additional desktop reviews and field surveys by qualified biologists 605 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 5 Cumulative Impacts to verify the results of the desktop reviews and to identify any resources that may not have been identified by the desktop reviews. These field surveys are conducted to identify and formally delineate any wetlands or other aquatic features within 500 feet of the proposed location. It is not uncommon for the ARIR to provide information that appears to conflict with the initial Hydrology Maps, however, the results of the ARIR are far more definitive and Chevron updates the Hydrology Maps to include the information from the ARIR. For the OGDP SKR 698-10 -BV Pad , the nearest aquatic feature to the WPS of the pad is the intermittent stream referred to as Deer Park Gulch located approximately 148 feet to the southeast. This intermittent stream is identified as Aquatic Sportfish Management Waters HPH, however, upon reviewing the ARIR CPW determined that this drainage does not contain sufficient year-round flows to support sportfish populations. Therefore, CPW granted waivers from Rule 1202.c.(1).S. and Rule 1202.a.(3) for this project. In addition, Chevron will implement several BMPs at th is location to minimize and mitigate any potential impacts to these and other aquatic features. In addition, production activities at the OGDP SKR 698 -10 -BV location or other past, present, or reasonably foreseeable production facilities or industrial development could increase the potential for accidental spills of fuels, lubricants, and other petroleum products, which could contaminate surface water within the ½-mile CIAA. All production from the well pad will be transported via buried flowlines to the existing CPF where additional production equipment will be located. There will be no routine storage of condensate or produced water on the pad, however, there will be a maintenance tank on the pad that will only be used when the wells and equipment on the well pad may need to be blown down. Spills of fuels or produced fluids from well pads and pipelines also have the potential to contaminate shallow alluvial groundwater. However, oil and gas development regulatory requirements to prevent spills from reaching surface and groundwater make these impacts unlikely, and therefore, represent a negligible potential cumulative impact within the CIAA. Total water volume needed for the Project would be approximately 1,444,000 barrels (bbls). Water for the Project would come from existing, permitted sources (both surface and groundwater) outside of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV area; no new water wells or water storage areas are proposed – refer to the Water Plan submitted with the Form 2A for details of the water sources. The use of more than 1.4 million bbls of water for the construction, drilling and completion of wells on the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location would cumulatively contribute to water use from other oil and gas development and agricultural activity within the CIAA. At the time of this application, the Piceance area lacks the infrastructure to source produced water for recycling. As development continues, the potential for recycled water in this region will also improve. In the interim, Chevron will continue to use water as efficiently as possible when drilling and completing these wells, to ensure that water usage is minimized. Chevron’s use of oil-based muds during drilling also reduces freshwater use at the Location. Minimization and mitigation measures intended to protect water resources within the CIAA are described in Section 4 and 5; Chevron’s commitment to implementation of these measures will further limit impacts to water resources within the CIAA. 606 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 6 Cumulative Impacts 3.3 Terrestrial and Aquatic Wildlife Resources and Ecosystems Cumulative impacts on terrestrial wildlife populations and habitats primarily result from surface- disturbing activities. Cumulative impacts to aquatic species primarily occur from water depletion and impacts to the quality of surface and groundwater, such as those discussed in Section 3.2. Wildlife Populations Surface Disturbance Impacts Development of the OGDP SKR 698-10 -BV location would temporarily incrementally increase the acres of cumulative surface disturbance from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable development within the 1-mile CIAA. Cumulative impacts to wildlife species can include habitat fragmentation, habitat loss, loss of foraging opportunities, and animal displacement; impacts that can last until successful final reclamation is completed. As summarized below and discussed in detail in the Wildlife Mitigation Plan submitted with the Form 2A, Chevron is implementing several measures to mitigate impact to wildlife. Chevron’s production design also provides for all fluids to be piped from the location to the CPF, which dramatically reduces the traffic traditionally associated with transporting these fluids. The proposed well pad and the associated access roads and flowline corridors are located within HPH, and Chevron will implement numerous wildlife-related BMPs for all development. The use of the existing well pad, which will require very little additional disturbance to accommodate the proposed wells, limits additional disturbance in HPH. Once this well pad undergoes interim reclamation, the resulting long-term disturbance will be less than exists for the storage yard currently. As noted above, CPW has granted Chevron a waiver from Rule 1202.c.(1).S. due to the fact that Deer Park Gulch cannot support sportfish populations. Additionally, Chevron is committed to performing all construction, drilling and completion operations outside of the timing limitations for Elk HPH. As noted above, the proposed well pad will be connected to the existing CPF via buried flowlines carrying oil, gas, and water to the production facility. As a result, there will be no truck traffic required to transport liquids from the well pad when the wells are in production which will dramatically decrease the potential impact to wildlife populations. Noise and Light Impacts Noise and light from anthropogenic activities both have the potential to adversely impact terrestrial and aquatic wildlife. Artificial light can have several effects on wildlife. Nocturnal animals rely on darkness for hunting, foraging, and scavenging. Predatory animals rely on darkness for hunting, while prey animals rely on the cover of darkness for protection from predators. Artificial light can also impact migratory birds including causing them to migrate too early or too late and miss ideal climate conditions for nesting, foraging, and other behaviors. Birds can also be attracted to sources of artificial light, which can lead to collisions and bird mortality. Artificial lights can also impact aquatic species. For example, glare from artificial lights can impact wetland or riparian habitats and interfere with activities such as nighttime croaking of 607 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 7 Cumulative Impacts frogs and toads, which can impact breeding and reproductive success and lead to reduced populations. Noise from human activity can also have an adverse impact on wildlife. Wildlife species use sound for a variety of reasons, including to navigate, find food, attract mates, and avoid predators. Anthropogenic noise, especially loud or high frequency noise intrusions, can be perceived by wildlife as a threat, causing them to flee an area. Noise can distract foragers such as big game species, reducing their efficiency of finding and handling food. Noise may increase physiological stress levels, which can impact behaviors and result in decreased physical health of animals and decreased reproduction. Noise can have indirect effects on wildlife, such as scaring away prey from an area predators rely on, or conversely, driving predators into prey habitat. Human introduced noise can also impede acoustic communication between wildlife or mask the sounds of an approaching predator or potential prey. Noise can also hinder animal communication by reducing the distance at which a signal can be detected, limiting the ability of the signal to reach its intended receiver, and decreasing the amount of information that can be extracted from a signal. For example, anthropogenic noise can reduce the ability of birds, small mammals, and insects to collect information on their surroundings, increase their predation risk (by masking the sounds of predators), and interfere with signals that are crucial for their breeding success and parental care. The pre-production potential for light and noise related impacts on wildlife will be decreased at the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location because Chevron intends to down-shield lighting during drilling and completion. Chevron is also committed to performing all construction, drilling and completion operations outside of the timing limitations for Elk HPH. Additionally, limited permanent lighting will be located on the well pad and will be switched so only on when in use, so long-term light and noise related impacts would be limited to headlights and vehicle engine noise from operational vehicles on location and enroute to and from the location during production. The majority of production-related traffic at the well pad will be during daylight hours. As indicated above, the use of pipelines to transport all fluids from the well pad will result in a dramatic reduction of traffic associated with production activities. In addition, given the existing oil and gas, industrial, and agricultural activity in and around the CIAA, local wildlife has likely become habituated, to some extent, to human presence, vehicle traffic, and operational activities (including associated noise and light from vehicle traffic) associated with these current land uses. Finally, the minimization and mitigation measures outlined in Sections 4 and 5 of this Plan would further diminish cumulative impacts on terrestrial and aquatic wildlife within the CIAA. 3.4 Soil Resources The CIAA for soils is a ½-mile radius around the Location. Construction of the OGDP SKR 698- 10-BV location would result in new disturbance of approximately 10 acres of soils. The soils present at the proposed location are detailed in the Dust Mitigation Plan submitted with the Form 2A. Cumulative impacts on soil resources can occur from any surface-disturbing activity that removes native vegetation and topsoil. These impacts can result in soil compaction, increased 608 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 8 Cumulative Impacts erosion, and sediment yield, all of which reduce soil productivity, stability, and viability. Of these impacts, compaction may be the most deleterious. Compaction affects the movement of water and air across the soil surface boundary. Infiltration, the movement of water into the soils, is critical for plant and soil health. If water cannot move into the soil quickly, it will pond and run off, leaving vegetation dry and dying, increasing erosion, and increasing flood frequency and magnitude. Compaction can also cause a shift from aerobic to more anaerobic organisms and may increase losses of nitrogen to the atmosphere (denitrification). Surface disturbance can also impact soil biological functions and viability because the disturbance can 1) enhance or degrade the microbial habitat, 2) add to or remove food resources, and/or 3) directly add or kill soil organisms. Most soil organisms – especially larger ones that contribute to soil health and viability – live in the top few inches of soil. Surface disturbance, compaction, and erosion disrupts and removes that habitat for soil organisms. As such, one of the most effective ways to reduce impacts to soil viability from surface disturbance is to protect and preserve topsoil. During the minimal additional construction at the location, topsoil will be segregated, stored and seeded to maximize the topsoil’s viability for future reclamation activities. Implementation of this and other minimization and/or mitigation measures listed in Sections 4 and 5 of this Plan, would help to lessen the potential for impacts to soils at the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location, and therefore, reduce its cumulative contribution to soil disturbance and loss of soil viability. 3.5 Vegetation The CIAA for vegetation is defined as a 1-mile buffer around the proposed OGDP SKR 698-10 - BV location. Past, present, and other reasonably foreseeable activities within the CIAA that have or will continue to affect vegetation communities include oil and gas development/other industrial activities, livestock grazing, and agriculture. Construction of the OGDP SKR 698-10- BV location, when combined with all past, present, and reasonably foreseeable activities in the CIAA, would have minimal to moderate impacts on vegetation across the CIAA. Yet in the context of cumulative impacts, each acre of vegetation disturbance would incrementally add to other existing and future surface disturbances in the CIAA by increasing erosion, incrementally adding to the overall native vegetation loss, and potentially increasing invasion or expansion of invasive and noxious weeds. Cumulative impacts for general vegetation would be mitigated in accordance with ECMC requirements. Interim reclamation would reduce the location and associated access road and flowline disturbance to approximately 2.4 acres. Minimization and mitigation measures (listed in Section 4 and 5 of this Plan) used to implement noxious weed management, erosion control, and apply dust abatement, would reduce impacts to native vegetation communities by reducing the potential for competition with invasive and noxious weed species, minimizing soil erosion and sedimentation, and reducing fugitive dust on plant surfaces. 609 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 9 Cumulative Impacts 3.6 Public Welfare – Noise, Odor, and Light The OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location is wholly located within rangeland and is zoned as Resource Lands by Garfield County. The nearest RBU to the WPS is over 1 mile to the south. The CIAA for Public Welfare is a 1-mile radius around the Location. There are no recreation areas within a 1-mile radius, and the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location is located in an area that has active oil and gas development meaning that visual impacts from oil and gas are already present in the CIAA. The scenic value of the location will not be impacted by the construction and operation of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location. Noise Noise during production operations at the well pad will be very limited. Visits to the pad by lease operators will be normally occur only during daylight hours. All produced gas and fluids will be piped from the well pad to the existing CPF which eliminates the trucking of fluids from the well pad and the noise impacts associated with this trucking. Odor Odor from existing and proposed oil and gas operations, including the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location, within the CIAA should not have any cumulative impact on residents because the nearest RBU is over 1 mile to the south. Chevron will utilize Group III drilling fluids to reduce odors from drilling operations. Cuttings will not be stockpiled, but rather they will be removed from the location on a regular and timely basis to reduce potential odor impacts. Other exploration and production activity wastes stored onsite would be stored in compatible containers or engineered containment devices. Wastes would be transported offsite via truck by a licensed transporter, and transportation frequencies would vary based on waste volumes. These measures would help to contain odors from being noticed within the CIAA. Additionally, the minimization and mitigation measures listed in Sections 4 and 5 would further limit the impacts of odor within the CIAA. Light Chevron’s development of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location would require work activities to be performed 24 hours per day during drilling, completion, drill-out, and flowback stages; all of which require the use of temporary lighting. Lighting needed for these activities would conform to nationally recognized industry and federally mandated safety standards. However, during nighttime work activities, lighting required for safe operations may be observed from locations beyond the boundaries of the well pad site. As such, nighttime drilling and completion activities would result in a short- term contribution to cumulative light pollution within the CIAA. However, light pollution BMPs (see Section 4.7) would be used to minimize light impacts during all phases of the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location’s proposed operations, including precautions to ensure that site lighting does not directly shine outside of the site boundaries, which would decrease potential light impacts on nearby receptors. Cumulative light impacts within the CIAA during these phases would be short-term and temporary. 610 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 10 Cumulative Impacts During production, operations would typically only occur during daylight hours. Permanent lighting on the well pad during production operations will be limited and switched so it is only on when needed . All permanent lighting will be shielded to reduce the amount of light leaving the location. Therefore, there would be little or no long-term contribution to cumulative light pollution within the CIAA from the OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location. 4.0 Minimization Measures ECMC defines “minimizing adverse impacts” as provided by § 34-60 -106(2.5), C.R.S., as “providing necessary and reasonable protections to reduce the extent, severity, significance, or duration of unavoidable direct, indirect and cumulative adverse impacts to public health, safety, welfare, the environment, or wildlife resources from oil and gas operations. Minimization measures reduce impacts to the smallest amount possible and can include operational and engineering controls. Chevron has committed to the fo llowing minimization measures for resources based on the cumulative impact analysis provided in this Plan. These minimization measures are included within the operational plans submitted as attachments to Chevron’s Form 2A’s for the proposed OGDP SKR 698-10-BV location. 4.1 Air Quality • Chevron will employ practices for continuous control of fugitive dust caused by operations. These practices shall include but are not limited to: o Speed restrictions on lease roads and location of 10 MPH during dryer conditions (if dust is visible) and 20 when dust is not visible. o Regular lease road maintenance to consist of, grading and recompacting the road surface with the optimum amount of water applied when the road surface becomes deteriorated or monthly when heavy traffic is present. o Restriction of construction activity during high-wind days. On windy days or days when dust becomes fugitive (leaves or threatens to leave the site) construction or activities will be halted until either fresh water can suppress dust or dust is no longer visible. o All public roads to be utilized for this project that are not paved will be treated in coordination with Garfield County to alleviate dust concerns. o Chevron uses a gravity fed box proppant delivery system that meets OSHA standards, rather than the historic pneumatic trailer proppant transfer system that blows sand out of the trailer into frac sand silos on the location; a method that required supplemental dust control to meet OSHA requirements. With a gravity fed proppant delivery system, the delivery container is also a well pad storage container, eliminating the need for frac sand silos on location. Storing frac sand in containers reduces sand dust during fracing operations by dropping sand directly from the container into the blender sand hopper. As a result of the gravity fed box proppant delivery system, Chevron does not anticipate any silica dust to migrate off the proposed well pad during completion operations. 611 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 11 Cumulative Impacts o Chevron uses automation on all new wells and production facilities to minimize truck traffic and to reduce the number of visits to location. Chevron monitors locations 24 hours a day in the Operations Control Center (OCC) and that has cut down on the need for physical location checks greatly. Chevron will also have camera coverage of the site that can be viewed remotely. • Chevron will not flare produced gas during normal operations. • Chevron will use supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) systems to monitor well operations, which will reduce emissions from vehicle traffic due to the reduced number of vehicle trips to the site. • Chevron has 24/7 monitoring through the OCC that allows for continuous monitoring of operating conditions when personnel are not on-site to identify and correct any improper operations as soon as possible. • Chevron will transport all fluids from the well pad to the CPF via buried pipelines which will eliminate the truck traffic associated with transporting these fluids. • Chevron completes regular audio/visual/olfactory observations at every active location which provides early detection of equipment malfunctions thereby minimizing emissions from leaks. • Chevron will use instrument air pneumatic control valves at the well heads. • Chevron will implement a Leak Detection and Repair program (LDAR). • As Chevron is committed to closed-loop drilling, there will be no emission-producing reserve pits. • Chevron’s green completions practices includes transporting all flowback fluids via buried pipelines to the CPF where they will be processed. 4.2 Public Health • Based on the airborne HAP concentrations estimated using HAP emission rates described in Section 3.1, no HAP is expected to exceed the target cancer risk or noncancer hazard index for chronic duration exposures within the location during pre- production or production. These results support the conclusion that HAP emissions are not expected to contribute to acute or chronic risks to human health within or beyond the location. Therefore, no additional minimization measures are required. 4.3 Water Resources • Chevron will implement a site-specific Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) (included with Form 2A) to protect Waters of the State that could receive stormwater runoff from the Location. • Chevron will manage potential pollutants located onsite by sealing, wrapping, covering, or having containment/protection while not actively being used in order to 612 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 12 Cumulative Impacts eliminate/minimize contact with stormwater runoff, and prevent discharges of chemicals or other materials from the site. • Chevron will practice proper storage, safe -handling, good housekeeping and spill prevention practices and procedures to prevent pollutants or contaminants from leaving the site. • Upon surface owner authorization and per ECMC Rules 615 and 318A.e(4), Chevron will collect baseline water quality samples from an appropriate set of water wells within the vicinity of the oil and gas location. Baseline samples will be collected prior to drilling (setting of conductor casing) operations for the initial site well. • Chevron will use SCADA to allow for rapid well shutdown in the event of a potential release. 4.4 Terrestrial and Aquatic Wildlife Resources and Ecosystems • Chevron is committed to performing all construction, drilling and completion operations outside of the timing limitations for Elk HPH. • Chevron will inform and educate employees and contractors on wildlife conservation practices, which includes no harassment or feeding of wildlife. • Chevron will consolidate and centralize collection and distribution facilities to minimize impact to wildlife. • Chevron will pipe all produced oil, water and gas from this well pad to the CPF, thereby significantly reducing traffic impacts. • Chevron will implement fugitive dust control measures. • Chevron will post speed limits and caution signs to the extent allowed by Garfield County. • Chevron will use remote monitoring of well production. • Chevron will reduce traffic associated with transporting drilling and completions water and produced liquids with pipelines, large tanks, or other measures. • Chevron will install automated emergency response systems (e.g., high tank alarms, emergency shutdown systems). 4.5 Soil Resources • Chevron will implement a site-specific Topsoil Management Plan and Stormwater Management Plan (Form 2A). Key control measures from those documents are included here: 613 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 13 Cumulative Impacts o During the minimal construction required for this Location, topsoil will be stripped and segregated into stockpiles that are reseeded to maximize the viability of the topsoil for future reclamation activities. o BMPs such as straw mulch, sediment basins, swales and perimeter ditches will be used to prevent excess erosion of soils from disturbed areas. These structures will be installed during construction and left in place and maintained for the life of the project or until the disturbed slopes have been revegetated and stabilized. o The site will be inspected bi-weekly by a third-party contractor for BMP integrity and current installation. Any deficiencies noted will be brought to the attention of the operator and addressed in a timely manner. o Chevron will limit construction activities during wet periods to avoid excess disturbance of areas surrounding operations. • Chevron will regrade cut and fill areas awaiting reclamation to match pre-existing contours to the nearest extent possible to provide long term erosion control and site stability. 4.6 Vegetation • Chevron will confirm that erosion and sedimentation controls are implemented as necessary before and after seeding operations, as detailed in the Site SWMP. • Chevron will monitor and maintain the vegetation on disturbed surfaces to promote native vegetation and to suppress invasive and noxious weeds. 4.7 Public Welfare – Noise, Odor, and Light Public Welfare – General • To minimize the possibility of fires during the construction phase, equipment, including welding trucks, will be equipped with fire extinguishers and spark arresters. • Where alignment of pipelines will cross or parallel roads, Chevron will provide warning signs to inform the public of the presence of the line. • Vehicle users associated with the oil field will be instructed to travel at low speed and remain on existing roads and well pads at all times. • Chevron will transport all fluids from the well pad to the CPF via buried pipelines which will eliminate the truck traffic associated with transporting these fluids. • Chevron will not truck any water to location for completions. Rather, temporary surface pipelines will be utilized. • Chevron will use SCADA to reduce the frequency of vehicle trips to the location to monitor well operations. 614 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 14 Cumulative Impacts Noise • Chevron will utilize a quiet frac fleet for completions operations. Odor • Chevron will ensure that oil and gas operations will be in compliance with the Department of Public Health and Environment, Air Quality Control Commission, Regulation No. 2 Odor Emission, 5 C.C.R. 1001-4, Regulation No. 3 (5 C.C.R. 1001-5), and Regulation No. 7 Section XVII.B.1 (a-c) and Section XII. • Chevron will utilize a freshwater mud system for surface hole. • Chevron will use Group III drilling fluids for this location . • Chevron will store oil-based drilling fluid not being used in the active mud system in closed, upright tanks. • To keep odor from oil base cuttings as low as possible, Chevron continuously hauls cuttings to an approved disposal facility throughout the drilling process. Chevron will not stockpile cuttings or store any large amount of cuttings on location. Trucks run continuously during daylight hours to keep the volume of cuttings on location at a minimum. • Chevron will wipe the OD and ID of the drill pipe to remove any residual mud upon tripping out of the hole. • Chevron will utilize a catch can system mounted around the BOP to catch any mud that falls through the rotary table, thereby preventing any spillage and reducing the source of odor. • Chevron will perform emission testing, as applicable, on natural gas-powered engines to ensure emission control devices are operating properly. Additionally, catalyst monitoring and maintenance activities recommended by the manufacturer or mandated by state and federal regulations will be performed to ensure that control devices are functioning as intended. Light Chevron will utilize BMPs to minimize light pollution which may include the following: • Use of LED fixtures, as feasible, to reduce skyglow. • Position lights in a downward direction where vertical light is not required. • Angle light away from off-site buildings. • Reduce lighting within well pad to the minimal level for safe pre-production activity. • Use of light sensors that automatically switch light sensors on and off on light masts. • Direct lights to drilling and completion tasks only. • Minimize permanent lighting on the well pad. 615 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 15 Cumulative Impacts 5.0 Mitigation Measures ECMC defines “mitigating adverse impacts” as “measures that compensate for unavoidable direct, indirect, and cumulative adverse impacts and loss of such resources from oil and gas operations.” Mitigation measures are used to offset the intensity or severity of impacts and can include compensatory actions and administrative controls. Chevron has committed to the following mitigation measures for resources based on the cumulative impact analysis provided in this Plan. 5.1 Air Quality • Minimization measures listed for air quality in Section 4 will address the potential impacts to air resources within the CIAA. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures for air quality are included. 5.2 Public Health • HAP emissions are not expected to contribute to acute or chronic risks to human health within or beyond the well pad Location. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures are required. 5.3 Water Resources • Minimization measures included in the site-specific SWMP for the OGDP SKR 698- 10-BV location and other measures included in Section 4 will address the potential impacts to water resources within the CIAA. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures are required. 5.4 Terrestrial and Aquatic Wildlife Resources and Ecosystems • During final reclamation, Chevron will re-contour and re-vegetate all roads and the pad to a stable condition to restore natural habitats for wildlife species, as is compatible with ongoing agricultural operations. 5.5 Soil Resources • Minimization measures listed for soil resources in Section 4 will address the potential impacts to these resources in the CIAA. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures for soil resources are included. 5.6 Vegetation • Chevron will reseed disturbed areas in the first favorable season following rig demobilization with species consistent with the plant community in the vicinity of the Location. • Chevron will monitor the site to identify areas of poor growth or areas that fail to germinate; these areas will be reseeded as needed. • Chevron will monitor the site for the presence of noxious weeds. If encountered, Chevron will employ a third-party consultant knowledgeable in identifying such 616 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 16 Cumulative Impacts species and implement weed control measures consistent and in compliance with the Colorado Noxious Weed Act. If necessary, Chevron will implement a weed control plan. 5.7 Public Welfare – Noise, Odor, and Light Noise • Chevron will respond to any noise complaints with appropriate measures to mitigate the noise. Odor • Minimization measures listed for odor in Section 4 will address the potential impacts from odors in the CIAA. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures for odors are included. Light • Minimization measures listed for lighting in Section 4 will address the potential impacts from lighting to the CIAA. Therefore, no additional mitigation measures for lighting are included. 617 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 1 Geologic Hazard Plan GEOLOGIC HAZARD PLAN Date: November 29, 2023 Location: OGDP SKR 698-10-BV Legal Description: Tract 72, Section 10 & 15,Township 6S, Range 98W, 6th PM, Garfield County, Colorado Chevron U.S.A., Inc. (Chevron) is to drill and produce two (2) wells on the existing SKR 698-10-BV Pad, located in Tract 72, Section 10 & 15,Township 6S, Range 98W, in Garfield County, Colorado. Per Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission (ECMC) Rule 304.b.(7).I., a Geologic Hazard Map (attached) was created to identify Geologic Hazards within a one-mile radius of the proposed working pad surface (WPS). Per ECMC Rule 304.c.(21), this Geologic Hazard Plan was developed to describe the hazards and proposed mitigation measures. Site Characteristics Research and investigations related to Geologic Hazards were completed for the existing SKR 698- 10-BV Pad and surrounding areas. As defined by the State of Colorado, a Geologic Hazard means a geologic phenomenon which is so adverse to past, current, or foreseeable construction or land use as to constitute a significant hazard to public health and safety or to property. The term includes but is not limited to: avalanches, landslides, rock falls, mudflows, and unstable or potentially unstable slopes; seismic effects; radioactivity; and ground subsidence. According to the Colorado Geological Survey (CGS) landslide information available on the ECMC’s GIS online, there are several landslides identified in the vicinity of the well pad. These landslides are at the base of or on the steep slopes of the adjacent plateaus and are common in this part of the Piceance Basin. The most common impact associated with these landslides results from rock fall, which is often triggered during precipitation events and freeze-thaw cycles. Mitigation Measures As noted above, rock fall associated with these landslides commonly occurs throughout this part of the Piceance Basin. Roads used to access the existing SKR 698-10-BV Pad have been constructed by Garfield County to try to alleviate impact from rock falls or landslide vents to the extent possible. The measures used include terracing above the roads and separation of the road from the base of the steep slopes as much as possible. The landslides identified to the north and east of the existing pad have sufficient distance from the pad or intervening topography that any rock fall or landslides from these areas would not impact the well pad. The landslide identified to the south is on the other side of the drainage to the south of the well pad and the well pad is elevated above that drainage so that any rock fall or landslides are not likely to reach the pad. Although the slope immediately to the north of the well pad is not identified as the location of landslides, the construction of the pad accounted for potential landslides from this slope by gradual sloping and terracing along the northern edge of the pad. Summary Geologic hazards were reviewed for the existing SKR 698-10-BV Pad and surrounding areas. The CGS identifies several landslide features in the vicinity. The landslides do not pose a risk to construction or production operations at the proposed pad which would constitute significant hazards to public, health, safety, or property. 618 OGDP SKR 698-10-BV 2 Geologic Hazard Plan Professional Geologist Certification I certify that I am a Professional Geologist, having met the educational requirements and professional work experience required by C.R.S. § 23-41-208(b). I have reviewed information pertaining to this Oil and Gas Location and the surrounding area and have identified the following Geologic Hazards: Landslides. The identified hazard does not pose a risk to construction or production operations nor are a hazard to public health, safety, or property in the area surrounding the Oil and Gas Location. ________________________________________ Doug Dennison Senior Permitting Coordinator Chevron/Noble Energy 619 ENGINEERING & LAND SURVEYING UELS, LLC Corporate Office * 85 South 200 East Vernal, UT 84078 * (435) 789-1017 GEOLOGIC HAZARDS MAP LEGEND: 80 0 ' 40 0 ' 0'80 0 ' NOTES: ·There are no known/permitted coal areas, landslides or earthquake records within 5280' of the working pad surface. https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/ (07-03-23) ·Fault (ECMC) - None - https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/ (07-03-23) ·Landslide (ECMC) - https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/ (07-03-23) ·Underground Mine (ECMC) - None - https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/ (07-03-23) ·Collapsible Soils (CGS) - https://cologeosurvey.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=a6f816b35fb64d3da096e84af661f070 (07-03-23) ·Radioactive Minerals (ECMC) - None - https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/ (07-03-23) ·Floodplain information was taken from ECMC GIS data. (Floodplain-Colorado 100-year Effective as of (2020) (07-03-23) FLOOD PLAINS SCALE 1" = 800'SURVEYED BY DRAWN BY SKR #698-10-BV PADTRACT 72, SECTIONS 10 & 15, T6S, R98W, 6th P.M.GARFIELD COUNTY, COLORADO CHEVRON U.S.A. INC. D.S.06-29-23 D.R.B.07-03-23 T6S T5S R 98 W 2000' OFFSET FROM WORKING PAD SURFACE EXISTING LOCATION: SKR #698-10-BV PAD EG-14 CRETACEOUS & TERTIARY FORMATIONS LANDSLIDE WORKING PAD SURFACE OIL & GAS LOCATION (LOD) REV: 2 09-29-23 T.L.L. (ADD IRRIGATION DRAINAGES & CERTIFICATION) I certify that I am a Professional Geologist, having met the educational requirements and professional work experience required by C.R.S., § 23-41-208(b). I have reviewed information pertaining to this Oil and Gas Location and the surrounding area, and have identified the Geologic Hazards within a one mile radius. TITLE Signature Doug DennisonLead Regulatory Affairs Spec. DATE 11/29/2023 620